Category Archives: International

VAT: Crowdfunding – What is taxable?

By   9 April 2020
0

What is crowdfunding?

Crowdfunding is the practice of funding a project or venture by raising many small amounts of money from a large number of people, typically via the internet on specifically designed platforms and is an alternative to traditional ways of raising finance. The model is usually based on three parties: the project initiator who proposes the idea or project to be funded, individuals or groups who support the idea, and a moderating organisation (the “platform”) that brings the parties together to launch the idea.

VAT Treatment

The VAT treatment of supplies that might potentially be made is no different to similar financing arrangements, for example; sponsorship, donations and investments made through more traditional routes. Whether a recipient of crowdfunding is liable to charge and pay VAT depends on the facts in each case.

Examples

Donations

  • where nothing is given in return for the funding, it will be treated as a donation and not liable to VAT – the position is the same where all that the funder receives is a bare acknowledgement, such as a mention in a programme or something similar

Goods and/or services

  • where the funder receives goods or services that have a real value associated with them, for example; clothing, tickets, DVDs, film viewings, output tax will be due

Combination

  • where the payment is for a combination of the two examples above, if it is clear that the donation element is optional then that part of the sponsorship can be treated as a non-taxable donation and the supply will be taxable. If a donation element cannot be carved out, it is likely that all of the payment will be considered as VATable

Investment

  • where the funding takes the form of an investment where the funder is entitled to a financial return such as; interest, dividends or profit share, any payment due to the funder is unlikely to be liable to output tax, The reason why most of these arrangements are outside the scope of VAT is that the provision of capital in a business venture is not seen as a supply for VAT purposes

Royalties

  • if the arrangement is that the funder receives royalties based on a supply of intellectual property or some other similar benefit the payment is likely to be consideration for a taxable supply and output tax will be due

VAT registration 

If income from the sources above which are deemed to be subject to VAT exceeds the VAT registration limit (currently £85,000 in any twelve-month period) the person, in whichever legal identity, such as; individual, company, partnership, Trust etc will be liable to register for VAT. If income is below this limit, it will be possible, but not mandatory to VAT register. The benefits of voluntary registration here.

Input tax recovery

If VAT registered, any input tax incurred on costs relating to crowdfunding is usually recoverable (see here for exceptions). However, if the costs relate to donations or some types of investment then input tax claims are specifically blocked as they would relate to non-business activities.

Commentary

There can be difficulties in establishing the tax liability of crowdfunding and in a broader sense “sponsorship” in general. However, experience insists that the biggest issue is initially identifying that there may be a VAT issue at all. If you, or your clients are involved in crowdfunding, or have sponsors, it would be prudent to review the VAT treatment of the activities.

VAT and Duty on exports and imports post Brexit – a guide

By   7 April 2020
0

Exports and Imports – post Brexit

VAT and Duty on exports and imports

With Brexit soon to become a reality, it is important that UK business understand the importance of exporting and importing goods. As matters stand, the UK will become a “third country” and as such will need to go through all the processes that apply to non-EU countries when goods cross borders to sales and purchases to/from existing EU countries. This mainly means customs duties applying to goods that have, to date, been duty free as the EU is a single market.

Whether importing or exporting, there are important VAT and duty rules and procedures. A business must ensure that it charges and pays the right amount of VAT and duty. The first step for moving goods into, or out of, the UK will be to obtain an EORI number. Details here.

Responsibilities for importers

  • the importer is normally responsible for clearing the goods through UK customs and paying any taxes
  • the supplier needs to provide the documentation an importer needs to clear the goods through customs (and to make payment to the supplier)
  • now, if you are importing (even from EU countries) you are likely to have to pay import duty. This cannot be reclaimed from HMRC
  • a business’ responsibilities depend on what it has agreed in the contract. To minimise the risk of disputes, your contract should use one of the internationally recognised Incoterms. These are explained here
  • check what import duty applies – import duty is based on the type of goods you are importing, the country they originate from and their value
  • HMRC’s Integrated Tariff sets out the classification of goods and the rates of duty in detail. Your Trade Association or your import agent may be able to assist with classification. You can find reputable freight forwarders through the British International Freight Association here 
  • an importer may need proof of the origin of the goods to claim reduced import duty for goods from certain countries
  • a valuation document is also normally required for imports above a set value
  • complete an import declaration. This is normally done using the Single Administrative Document (SAD)
  • pay VAT and duty to get the goods released
  • the VAT applicable is the normal UK rate for the imported goods when sold in the UK
  • regular importers can defer payment of VAT and duty by opening a deferment account with HMRC. A security payment will need to be provided and payments must be via Direct Debit
  • From 1 January 2021 Postponed Accounting for import VAT to be introduced for all goods including those from the EU
  • account for VAT on returns
  • HMRC will send a C79 certificate showing the import VAT you have paid
  • VAT on imports (supported by C79 evidence) may be claimed in the same way as reclaims of input tax incurred on purchases in the UK
  • import duty cannot be reclaimed

Responsibilities for exporters

    • the exporter is normally responsible for clearing goods outwards through UK customs
    • the customer is normally responsible for overseas customs clearance and taxes (depending on the Incoterms). Further details on how other countries handle import duties and taxes are available from the Department for International Trade
    • the exporter will need to provide its customer with the documentation they need to clear goods into their country (and to pay you)
    • the exporter’s responsibilities depend on what it has agreed in the contract (see Incoterms above)
    • the exporter will need to provide its customer with the documents they need to import the goods into their country. These documents can also be part of the process of getting paid
    • as a minimum, the seller will need documents recording details of the:
    • exporter
    • customer
    • goods and their value
    • export destination
    • how the goods will be transported
    • route they will take
  • keep copies of all documents giving details of all the sales which have been made.
  • record the value of your exports on your VAT return
  • consider any responsibility you have for overseas customs clearance and taxes. Normally, as an exporter, you will have agreed that your customer handles this. However, take specialist advice, or use an expert agent, if you are responsible – this will depend on Incoterms

Tips

  • freight forwarders can handle customs clearance as well as transport
  • exporting can be simpler if you choose to sell to a single agent or distributor in an overseas country. However, this may not suit your export strategy
  • exports are usually zero-rated. However, exporters must keep proof that the goods have been physically exported along with normal commercial documentation
  • the exporter must declare the export. This is usually done by completing a Single Administrative Document (SAD), also known as form C88

Excise duty

  • check whether any goods being purchased are subject to excise duty
  • excise duty is payable on; fuel, alcohol and tobacco products
  • if goods are subject to excise duty, it is paid at the same time as payments for VAT and import duty are made
  • VAT is charged on the value of the goods plus excise duty

Customs warehouses

If you expect to store imports for a long time it will be worth considering using a Customs warehouse.

  • goods stored in a customs warehouse, will not be subject to import duty and VAT until they are removed from the warehouse
  • storage ‘in bond’ is often used for products subject to excise duty, such as wine and cigarettes, although it is not limited to these goods

Relief for re-exported goods

  • it may be possible to take advantage of Inward Processing Relief (IPR) rules so that no import duty and VAT is payable
  • IPR can apply to imports that you process before re-exporting them

If you import or export regularly, find out about alternative procedures

  • For example, businesses that import regularly and in large volumes can use processes such as Customs Freight Simplified Procedures.

Summary

If you are new to acquisitions, importing or exporting, it may be worthwhile talking to an expert. This article only scratches the surface of the subject. There can be significant savings made by accurately classifying goods, and applying the correct procedures and rates will avoid assessments and penalties being levied. Planning may also be available to defer when tax is paid on imports and acquisitions.

Budget 2020 – VAT implications

By   11 March 2020
0

A summary of how the 2020 budget changes VAT rules:

e-publications

Zero rating will apply to e-publications from 1 December 2020. This brings e-publications in line with traditional printed matter. The zero rate will apply to:

  • e-books
  • e-newspapers
  • e-magazines
  • academic e-journals

Presumably, this brings an end to HMRC’s arguments set out in the News Corp case.

Postponed Accounting

From 1 January 2021 postponed accounting will apply to all imports of goods, including those from the EU. This will provide an important boost to those VAT registered UK businesses which are integrated in international supply chains as they adapt to the UK’s position post Brexit.

Sanitary products

From 1 January 2021 the zero rate will apply to women’s sanitary products. This is calculated to save the average women £40 over her life.

Consultation

A consultation paper will be published to gather views on the potential approach to duty and tax-free goods policy post Brexit.

Cross-border goods policy

An informal consultation process will be launched in spring 2020 on the VAT and Excise treatment of goods crossing UK borders after Brexit.

Fund management

As announced on 4 March 2020 the government is legislating to clarify when fund management services are exempt from VAT.

Financial services

An industry working group will be set up to review how financial services are treated for VAT purposes. Presumably how Brexit will affect such services.

“Quick Fixes” Directive

Legislation will be introduced to simplify rules for the VAT treatment of intra-EU movements of call-off stock, allowing businesses to delay accounting for VAT until the goods are called-off.

Partial Exemption

Following the recent call for evidence on the simplification of the VAT rules on Partial Exemption and the Capital Goods Scheme, the government has said it will continue to engage with businesses in relation to their responses and will publish a response in due course.

Commentary

These proposed measures will be broadly be welcomed by business. Especially those in relation to e-publications and Postponed Accounting. It was widely expected that HMRC would lose its argument that e-publications and hard copy publications should be treated differently in any case. Postponed Accounting takes us back to the pre-1990s era. It looks very much like this means a “No-Deal” and although Postponed Accounting may be an easement for some aspects, it remains unnecessary if an agreement with the EU can be reached. However, there appears to be no political will nor appetite to reach such an agreement, so business suffers.

VAT: Interaction of Clawback and the Capital Goods Scheme – The Stichting Schoonzicht case

By   10 March 2020
0

Latest from the courts

The difference between intended use and first actual use of an asset.

In the Dutch case of Stichting Schoonzicht (C‑791/18) the AG was asked to provide an opinion on the interaction between clawback and the Capital Goods Scheme (CGS) via Directive 2006/112/EC, Articles 185 and 187. Details of the CGS here. In the UK clawback is set out in The General Regulations 1995, Reg 108.

Background

Stichting Schoonzicht constructed a number of apartments which it intended to sell on completion. This would have been a taxable supply and afforded full input tax recovery on the costs incurred on the development. Unfortunately, due to market conditions, the business was unable to find buyers at the appropriate sale price. Therefore, a decision was made to let some of the flats on a short-term basis until the market picked up. This was done and created an exempt supply. The intention to make taxable supplies remained, but in the meantime, exempt supplies had actually been made. This could affect the original input tax claim. Details of partial exemption here.

Technical 

The Dutch referring court entertained doubts about the compatibility of the ‘first-use full adjustment’ requirement provided for under Netherlands law and the CGS.

So the issue was whether the CGS (Article 187 of the VAT Directive) applied such that any required adjustments to the initial input tax claim could be made via a CGS calculation, or whether, as the Dutch authorities contended, there should be a one-off clawback of the input tax previously claimed.

Decision

In the AG’s opinion, the Dutch tax authorities could clawback 4/7 of the input tax on the construction (as four of the flats were let and three remained unoccupied). The AG decided that the CGS could co-exist with clawback and that EU Member States are allowed to adjust the initial deduction of input tax using clawback where actual use varies from intended use. A distinction was made between clawback and the CGS. The CGS is intended to adjust input tax claims as a result of fluctuations in the taxable use of capital assets over a period of time (ten years for buildings in the UK).

Commentary

In the UK, there are published easements for input tax recovery in similar circumstances: “VAT: Partial Exemption – adjustments when house builders let their dwellings”. However, this is an interesting AG opinion, is worth a read and it will be interesting to see how this develops. However, with prior planning, this situation may be avoided in the UK (where new house sales are zero rated).

VAT exemptions widened by Finance Order 2020

By   4 March 2020
0

Finance Order 2020

The government has laid the Value Added Tax (Finance) Order 2020 (“Finance Order 2020”) on 4 March 2020 to widen the VAT exemption for the management of investment funds.

The Finance Order 2020 will come into effect on the 1st April 2020 and will provide for exemption for the management of certain pension funds (as defined) and will also remove the current restriction on the type of assets that a close-ended collective investment undertaking can invest in for its management to qualify for exemption.

It replaces the Value Added Tax Finance (EU Exit) Order 2019 (“Finance Order 2019”) which was revoked last July, following discussion with industry about the need for certainty about the date of implementation and provide sufficient lead in time. The Finance Order 2020 will make the same changes to the legislation as the Finance Order 2019 would have made except that (1) new paragraph (k) inserted into Item 9 now refers to a ‘qualifying’ pension fund as opposed to a ‘recognised’ pension fund and (2) the changes will not apply in the case of pension funds that are established overseas (ie; outside the UK and the EU).

VAT: EC AG’s Opinion – Are aphrodisiacs food?

By   2 March 2020
0

Latest from the courts

It’s rare to come across anything vaguely sexy about VAT, but hey ho, aphrodisiacs were the subject of the AG’s opinion in the case of “X” – the name of the Dutch business. The document was published by the European Commission (EC) and is here but unavailable in the English language, presumably as a result of Brexit, unless anyone knows of any other reason.

Opinion

 The AG, M. Maciej Szpunar decided that no, aphrodisiacs cannot be treated as food via Directive 2006/112/CE – Article 98 and are therefore not subject to a reduced rate (which would have been zero rated in the UK). The relevant element was:

“Foodstuffs” intended for human consumption “refers to products containing nutrients, and which are in principle consumed for the purpose of supplying said nutrients to the human body”. Products which are normally used to supplement or replace foodstuffs “Means products which are not foodstuffs, but which contain nutrients and are consumed in place of foodstuffs to supply these nutrients to the body, as well as products ingested in order to stimulate the nutritional functions of food or products used to replace them.

Therefore, in the AG’s opinion, the powders and capsules sold by X are different to foodstuffs and supplements and were not subject to the reduced rate. The fact that they may contain elements of nutrition did not override that they were intended to stimulate sexual desire and it was not the intention of the legislation that such products should be subject to the reduced rate as they were not “essential goods”.

That, of course, does not mean that foods which are said to contain aphrodisiac properties such as; asparagus, oysters, watermelons, celery and pomegranates are not reduced rated.

I doubt that Aphrodite – the Greek goddess of love and beauty, knew that ultimately there would be a court case on the rate of indirect tax applicable to such, err; “stimulants”.

AG’s Opinion

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) consists of one judge from each member state, assisted by eleven Advocates General whose role is to consider the written and oral submissions to the court in every case that raises a new point of law, and deliver an impartial opinion to the court on the legal solution.

VAT overpayments – HMRC to consider changes

By   24 February 2020
0

VAT overpayments – New direct claims?

If a recipient of a supply makes an overpayment of VAT (usually as a result of standard rated tax being charged when a supply is reduced rated, zero rated or exempt) the remedy for the customer is to go to the supplier to obtain a new invoice/VAT only credit note and. repayment of the VAT paid. However, this can cause practical problems, disputes and an actual cost if a supplier has ceased business or become insolvent. HMRC has recognised that if the supplier has paid output tax on the supply then there is an inherent unfairness.

Following the decision in PORR Építési Kft. (C 691/17) which considered the principles of; proportionality, fiscal neutrality and effectiveness, HMRC invited interested parties to discuss a direct HMRC claim process where the taxpayer has pursued a refund via its supplier for overpaid incorrectly charged VAT but where, as stated in the cases, “recovery is impossible or excessively difficult”. In such cases the taxpayer “must be able to address its application for reimbursement to the tax authority directly”. In the past, HMRC has directed that such claims from them are pursued via the High Court (or County Court if under £30,000). The meeting discussed the new route to direct claims without initial court action including guidance, time limits and claim processes.

We await the outcome eagerly as this situation is quite common, I have found it is an issue particularly in; property and construction supplies, Financial Services and cross-border transactions (place of supply issues). If HMRC are minded to introduce a “direct claim” this will bring welcome relief to taxpayers and introduce fairness for all parties and do away with windfalls received by HMRC.

A Round-Up of three new EU VAT measures

By   24 February 2020
0

With the end of the Brexit transition period looming, the EU have announced new measures:

e-commerce VAT fraud

The first measure is the European Commission (EC) approving (this month) new measures to transmit and exchange payment data in order to fight e-commerce VAT fraud. Member States will be assisted in their fight against e-commerce VAT fraud by the launch of a Central Electronic System of Payment (CESOP) information arrangement.

CESOP will keep records of cross-border payment information within the EU, as well as payments to third countries or territories, for a period of five years. This will allow tax authorities to properly control the correct fulfilment of VAT obligations on cross-border Business to Consumer (B2C) supplies of goods and services.

The measures will be implemented on 1 January 2025. 

Simplified rules for small businesses

The EC has also recently adopted simplified VAT rules applicable to small businesses. The new measures are intended to reduce the administrative burden and compliance costs for small enterprises and create a fiscal environment which will help small enterprises grow and trade across borders more efficiently.

The measures foresee that small enterprises will be able to qualify for simplified VAT compliance rules where their annual turnover remains below a threshold set by a Member State concerned, which cannot be higher than 85 000 EUR. Under certain conditions, small enterprises from other member states, which do not exceed this threshold, will also be able to benefit from the simplified scheme, if their total annual turnover in the whole of the EU does not exceed 100 000 EUR.

The new rules will apply as of 1 January 2025.

New rules for exchange of VAT payment data

In addition to the anti e-commerce fraud proposals above, new measures will enable Member States to collect, in a harmonised way, the records made electronically available by payment service providers, such as banks. These complement the VAT regulatory framework for e-commerce coming into force in January 2021 which introduced new VAT obligations for online marketplaces and simplified VAT compliance rules for online businesses.

The new measures will apply as of 1 January 2024.

How these new incentives affect UK businesses remains to be seen as our future trading relationship with the EU is, to put it diplomatically, unclear.

Brexit – Introduction of new import controls on EU goods

By   17 February 2020
0

More red tape and delays

The government has announced new plans to introduce import controls on EU goods at the border from 1 January 2021, the day after the end of the Brexit transition period.

This will almost certainly mean additional complexity and delays at borders and will damage businesses, especially those which operate on a Just In Time (JIT) basis or import fresh food, flowers or any other goods which are subject to rapid deterioration.

It is difficult to divorce politics from commerce in these circumstances, but I have avoided commenting on this decision on a political basis, although I think it is fair to say I am not in favour.

The government commented that all UK exports and imports (currently called dispatches and acquisitions from the EU) will be treated equally. This will mean traders in the EU and GB will have to submit customs declarations and be liable to goods’ checks. It was also confirmed that the policy easements put in place for a potential No Deal Brexit will not be reintroduced as businesses have time to prepare. (HMRC have withdrawn a collection of guidance on issues including tariffs, origin, and quotas, which was prepared for a potential No Deal Brexit).

It is difficult to identify how businesses could have had time to prepare as HMRC guidance was unhelpful on this point and it was, and still is, unclear what precise arrangements a business has to prepare for. It is assumed that this a unilateral UK’ decision and it cannot be helpful for cooperation negotiations, unless these controls are what are actually wanted. In the document, it is stated that: ”Business can prepare for border controls by making sure they have an Economic Operator Registration and Identification (EORI) number, and also looking into how they want to make declarations such as using a customs agent”. That is the extent of the advice provided and repeats what has been said before.

Without wanting to amplify government propaganda, but in the interest of even-handedness, below are the reasons given for implementing import controls:

  • to keep our borders safe and secure so we know who’s coming in and how often, what they are bringing in, and why
  • to ensure we treat all partners equally as we begin to negotiate our own trading arrangements with countries around the world
  • to collect the right customs, VAT and excise duties
  • the EU has said it will enforce checks on our goods entering the Eurozone. We will likewise enforce our own rules for goods entering the UK

Also, HMRC extended the deadline for businesses to apply for customs support funding to 31 January 2021. To date, applications have been made for around £18.5 million out of a possible £26 million.

This announcement follows on from the consideration of the introduction of UK freeports here.

I hope that there are enough customs agents to go round, although the lack of any evidence that HMRC is recruiting new Customs officers suggests that perhaps it is not fully prepared itself.