Category Archives: Latest VAT news

VAT: The importance of due diligence. The 50 Five (UK) Limited case

By   10 May 2022
1

Latest from the courts

In the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) case of 50 Five (UK) Limited the issue was the VAT rate applicable to energy saving materials. An additional twist was that there was a sale of the business between the tax point of the relevant supplies and HMRC’s assessment.

Background

The appeal was brought in the name of the Appellant in respect of assessments raised by HMRC against the company prior to the date on which it was purchased by the present owners. The present owners were not made aware of the assessment at the time of purchase. It had not been disclosed to them as part of the due diligence which was undertaken.

The Appellant’s business was that of supply and installation of heating and hot water systems. The customers were supplied with fully installed systems. The Appellant did not ask the customers to separately source the parts for such systems and then simply fit them. These supplies were treated as those of energy saving materials and the reduced rate of 5% was applied.

HMRC raised an assessment after taking the view that the supply should have properly been standard rated at 20%.

Decision

The FTT decided that legislation which permits the sale of energy saving materials at the reduced rate of VAT apply only where the supply of those materials is independent of an installation service. In this case, as the Appellant was the provider of the goods, and also the installer, the supply to the end customer was standard rated (a composite supply).

It was noted that this outcome was counter intuitive and the result does indeed seem unfair to the taxpayer, but as there was no reasonable prospect of the appeal succeeding, it was struck out.  The assessment and interest was now payable by the new owners.

Commentary

An unfortunate outcome for the new owners, but it highlights three VAT issues:

  • always carry out appropriate due diligence when buying a business. VAT is often an issue and if the buyer had discovered the assessment, it could have either abandoned the purchase, or negotiated on the price
  • never assume that a lesser rate of VAT applies without carrying out appropriate research or seeking advice
  • always consider whether a supply is separate or composite. This is a difficult area of the tax as the amount of case law testifies

The only recourse the new owners have now is taking action against the sellers of the business.

VAT: Global Accounting simplification

By   10 May 2022
2

VAT: Second Hand Scheme  – Global Accounting simplification

Overview

The problem with the VAT Second-Hand Goods Scheme is that details of each individual item purchased, and then later sold, has to be recorded. This requirement can lead to a lot of paperwork and an awful lot of administration which, obviously, many businesses are not too keen to comply with.

Global Accounting is an optional, simplified variation of the Second Hand Margin Scheme (MS).

It differs from the standard MS because rather than accounting for the margin achieved on the sale of individual items VAT is calculated on the margin achieved between the total purchases and total sales in a particular accounting period without the requirement to establish the mark up on each individual item.  It is beneficial if a business buys and sells bulk volume, low value eligible goods, and is unable to maintain the detailed records required of businesses who use the standard MS.

There two significant differences in respect of Global Accounting compared to the standard MS. The first difference is that losses on an item are automatically offset against profits on items. Thus losses and profits are offset together in the period. In the standard MS no VAT is due if a loss is made on an item, but that loss cannot be offset against any other profit.  There is also a timing advantage with Global Accounting because all purchases made in the period are included, even if those goods are not actually sold in the same period.

Goods which may be included in Global Accounting

Global Accounting can be used for all items which are eligible under the standard MS.  However, the following goods cannot be included in Global Accounting:

  • individual items costing more than £500 (although these can be accounted for via the standard MS)
  • aircraft, boats and outboard motors,
  • caravans and motor caravans,
  • horses and ponies, and
  • motor vehicles, including motorcycles; except those broken up for scrap.

Starting to use the scheme

When a business starts using Global Accounting, it may find that it already has eligible stock on hand.  It may include the value of this stock when it calculates the total purchases at the end of the first period.  If a business does not take its stock on hand into account, it will have to pay VAT on the full price, rather than on the margin achieved, when it is sold.

Note: any goods bought on an invoice which shows a separate VAT figure are not eligible for resale under the scheme.

The calculation

VAT is calculated at the end of each tax period. Because you can take account of opening stock in your scheme calculations, you may find that you produce a negative margin at the end of several periods. In other words, your total purchases may exceed your total sales. In such cases, no VAT is due. But you must carry the negative margin forward to the next period as in the following example:

Period One

  1. a)      Total purchase value of stock on hand 10,000
  2. b)      Total purchases 2,000
  3. c)      Total sales 8,000

Margin = c – (a+b) = (4,000)

Because this is a negative margin there is no VAT to pay.  However, negative margin must be carried forward into the next period as follows:

Period Two

  1. a)      Negative margin from previous period 4,000
  2. b)      Total purchases 1,000
  3. c)      Total sales 7,000
  4. d)      Margin = c – (a + b), sales minus (purchases plus negative margin), £7,000 – (£1,000 + £4,000) 2,000
  5. e)      VAT due = margin (£2,000) × VAT fraction (1/6) 333.33

There is no negative margin to carry forward this time. Therefore, in the third period, the margin is calculated solely by reference to sales less purchases.

The negative margin may only be offset against the next Global Accounting margin. It cannot be offset against any other figure or record.

Global Accounting Records and Accounts

A business does not need to keep all the detailed records which are required under the normal MS – for instance, you do not have to maintain a detailed stock book.

Global Accounting records do not have to be kept in any set way but they must be complete, up to date and clearly distinguishable from any other records.  A business must keep records of purchases and sales as set out below, together with the workings used to calculate the VAT due.

If HMRC cannot check the margins declared from the records, VAT will be due on the full selling price of the goods sold, even if they were otherwise eligible for the scheme.

Buying goods under Global Accounting

When a business buys goods which it intends to sell under Global Accounting it must:

  • check that the goods are eligible for Global Accounting
  • obtain a purchase invoice. If a business buys from a private individual or an unregistered entity, the purchaser should make out the invoice at the time the goods are purchased.  If purchased from another VAT-registered dealer, the dealer must make out the invoice at the time of sale, and
  • enter the purchase details of the goods in your Global Accounting purchase records.  The purchase price must be the price on the invoice which has been agreed between you and the seller.

You cannot use the scheme if VAT is shown separately on the invoice.

If you are buying from a private individual or an unregistered business, you must make out the purchase invoice yourself.

When selling goods under Global Accounting

If the purchase conditions above apply, Global Accounting may be used when the goods are sold by:

  • recording the sale in the usual way
  • issuing a sales invoice for sales to other VAT-registered dealers and keeping a copy of the invoice, and
  • transferring totals of copy invoices to the Global Accounting sales record or summary
  • you must be able to distinguish at the point of sale between sales made under Global Accounting and other types of transaction

Leaving the scheme

If a business stops using Global Accounting for any reason, it must make a closing adjustment to take account of purchases for which it has taken credit, but which have not been sold (closing stock on hand). The adjustment required does not apply if the total VAT due on stock on hand is £1,000 or less. In the final period for which the business uses the scheme, it must add the purchase value of its closing stock to the sales figure for that period.  In this way VAT will be paid (at cost price) on the stock for which the business previously had credit under the scheme.

Items sold outside the scheme

If goods are sold which had been included in a business’ Global Accounting purchase (for example, they are exported), a business must adjust its records accordingly.  This is done by subtracting the purchase value of the goods sold outside the scheme from the total purchases at the end of the period.

Stolen or destroyed goods

If a business loses any goods through breakage, theft or destruction, it must subtract their purchase price from your Global Accounting purchase record.

Repairs and restoration costs

A business may reclaim the VAT it is charged on any business overheads, repairs, restoration costs, etc. But it must not add any of these costs to the purchase price of the goods sold under the scheme.

For further advice on any global accounting, used goods schemes, or any other special VAT schemes please contact me.

A VAT Did you know?

By   27 April 2022
1

Aphrodisiacs can be food and therefore VAT free. Capsules, drops, powders and sprays presented as aphrodisiacs that stimulate libido are intended for human consumption and are taken orally.  The fact that consumption of the product may have positive effects on the sexual desire of the person ingesting it is irrelevant.

VAT: Updated Road Fuel Scale Charges from 1 May 2022

By   25 April 2022
0

Access the updated VAT Fuel Scale Charges to apply from the 1 May 2022 here They will apply VAT periods starting on or after that date.

HMRC has published new VAT Road Fuel Scale Charges (RFSC) which apply from 1 May 2022 to 30 April 2023.

RFSC

If a business reclaims VAT incurred on road fuel, it will be required recognise the private use element of the fuel.

The RFSC simplifies accounting for VAT on the private use of fuel by motorists. The RFSC is calculated according to a car’s CO2 emissions and the fixed charge is added to output VAT, on the VAT return (in effect, the business supplies to fuel to the individual). The use of this charge is optional, the alternative is to keep detailed mileage records.

Details of these, and other motoring expenses here.

A quick RFSC calculator/ready-reckoner here.

VAT: Place of belonging. The Berlin Chemie A Menarini case

By   13 April 2022
2

Latest from the courts

The place of belonging of a business or other person is an important tenet of the tax. I have considered this issue at length here and recent case law here.

A recent CJEU case involved a situation where a business had a registered office in one country and, potentially (hence the appeal) a fixed establishment in another.

Background

“Berlin” used a “third party” to receive certain services. Does this entry represent a fixed establishment for Berlin if it has a sufficient degree of permanence and a suitable structure in terms of technical and human resources? If yes, is it is necessary for those human and technical resources to belong to the company receiving the services or whether it is sufficient for that company to have immediate and permanent access to such resources through a related company, of which it is major shareholder?

Technical

The wording of Article 44 of the VAT Directive and Article 11(1) of Implementing Regulation No 282/2011 do not provide any details as to whether human and technical resources must belong to the company that receives the services.

Decision

The CEUJ ruled that, simple control or ownership, of another entity is insufficient to create a fixed establishment for VAT purposes. Consequently, a third party location does not inevitably represent a fixed establishment by dint of control/ownership.

Having made that comment, the court impressed that the decision should be made “in the context of the economic and commercial reality”.

The analysis of the place of belonging should recognise that it is not necessary for the fixed establishment to own the resources, but there should be control over these resources in the same way as an “owner”.  A fixed establishment is characterised by a suitable structure which enables a business to receive and use services supplied to them for their own needs and not by the decision power of a certain structure that businesses have put in place.

Commentary

Although an EU case, it could impact UK businesses who make supplies to EU recipients and particularly, if there is a “network” of offices or business locations in various EU Member States. Overseas suppliers to (potentially) UK business with various business premises and structures will need to recognise this ruling in order to establish the place of supply (and hence what country’s VAT and at what rate to apply).

This decision provides some helpful clarity, which may be summarised as: In principle, a subsidiary does not always create a fixed establishment.

VAT: Motoring costs – A guide

By   8 April 2022
0

VAT Basics

Nearly all businesses incur car motoring expenses, so here is a guide to the VAT impact:

Buying a car

A business cannot recover the VAT on a car purchase, unless it:

Leasing a car

If a business leases a ‘qualifying car’ for business purposes it will normally be unable to recover 50% of the VAT charged. The 50% block is to cover the private use of the car.

However, a 100% reclaim is possible if it is to be used for hire with a driver for carrying passengers or providing driving instruction.

The 50% block applies to all the VAT on charges paid for the rental of the car. This includes:

  • optional services — unless they’re supplied and identified separately from the leasing supply on the tax invoice
  • excess mileage charge — if it forms part of a supply of leasing but not if it was incurred on an excess mileage charge that forms part of a separate supply of maintenance

Fuel

The options for claiming input tax on road fuel are as follows:

  • claim 100% of the VAT charged. This is possible if fuel is bought for business motoring only or for both business and private motoring and the appropriate fuel scale charge (see below) is applied on the value of supplies of fuel for private use
  • use detailed mileage records to separate business mileage from private mileage and only claim for the business element
  • claim no input tax

Road Fuel Scale Charge

A scale charge is a way of accounting for output tax on road fuel bought by a business for cars which is then put to private use. If a business uses the scale charge, it can recover all the VAT charged on road fuel without having to split mileage between business and private use. The charge is calculated on a flat rate basis according to the carbon dioxide emissions of the car. The charges are set out in the fuel scale charge table.

Mileage records

HMRC calculation example:

  • Total mileage: 4,290
  • Business mileage: 3,165
  • Cost of fuel: £368.
  • Business mileage: £368 × (3,165 ÷ 4,290) = £271.49
  • Claimable input tax: £271.49 × VAT fraction = £45.25

Fuel paid for by employees

If a business reimburses its employees for fuel used it can treat the VAT they paid as its input tax. But the business must be able to show that it has reimbursed them for their actual expenditure on the fuel. If fuel bought by employees for business is put into private use, the business must account for output tax on the private use using the scale charges or the value.

Electric vehicles

Details of input tax recovery and output tax due here.

Input tax on repairs 

If a vehicle is used for business purposes, there is a 100% reclaim of the VAT charged on repairs and maintenance as long as the business paid for the work and the vehicle is used for some business purposes. It does not matter if the vehicle is used for private motoring or if you have chosen not to reclaim VAT on road fuel (see below).

Other motoring expenses

Input tax incurred on all other business motoring expenses, eg; fleet management charges or parking charges is fully recoverable input tax.

Selling a car

If a car is sold on which input tax was recovered, eg; a driving school car, VAT is due on the full selling price. The supply of these vehicles are cannot be made under the second hand margin scheme.

If a car is sold where VAT was charged on purchase but could not be recovered there is no VAT due on the sale of it. Such a supply is exempt and must be consider in any partial exemption calculation. For most businesses this will not be an issue.

If a business sells a car where VAT was not charged when it was purchased, eg: from a private individual or from a dealer who sold it under the second-hand margin scheme, no VAT will be due unless the sale was at a higher value than the purchase price. In which case VAT will be due under the margin scheme.

NB: The VAT rules for commercial vehicles will differ.

VAT – Overseas holiday lets: A warning

By   8 April 2022
0

Do you, or your clients, own property overseas which you let to third parties when you are not using it yourself?

It is important to understand the VAT consequences of owning property overseas.

The position of UK Holiday Lets

It may not be commonly known that the UK has the highest VAT threshold in the EC. This means that for many ‘sideline’ businesses such as; the rental of second or holiday properties in the UK, the owners, whether they are; individuals, businesses, or pension schemes, only have to consider VAT if income in relation to the property exceeds £85,000 pa, and this is only likely if a number of properties are owned.

It should be noted that, unlike other types of rental of homes, holiday lettings are always taxable for VAT purposes.

Overseas Holiday Lets

EU Member States have nil thresholds for foreign entrepreneurs.  This means that if any rental income is received, VAT registration is likely to be compulsory. Consequently, a property owner that rents out a property abroad will probably have a liability to register for VAT in the country that the property is located.  Failure to comply with the domestic legislation of the relevant Member State may mean; payment of back VAT and interest and fines being levied. VAT registration however, does mean that a property owner can recover input tax on expenditure in connection with the property, eg; agent’s fees, repair and maintenance and other professional costs.  This may be restricted if the home is used for periodical own use.

Given that every country has differing rules and/or procedures to the UK, it is crucial to check all the consequences of letting property overseas. Additionally, if any other services are supplied, eg; transport, this gives rise to a whole new (and significantly more complex) set of VAT rules.

A final word of warning; I quite often hear the comment “I’m not going to bother – how will they ever find out?”

If an overseas property owner based in the UK is in competition with local letting businesses, those businesses generally do not have any compulsion in notifying the local authorities. In addition, I have heard of authorities carrying out very simple initiatives to see if owners are VAT registered. In many resorts, income from tourism is vital and this is a very important revenue stream for them so it is well policed.

Please contact us if you are affected by this matter; we have the resources to advise and act on a worldwide basis.

A VAT Did you know?

By   30 March 2022
1

So that’s what it’s called….. From HMRC guidance – “For the purposes of establishing the place of supply of services, stallion nominations (The right to nominate a mare to be covered by a stallion in one breeding season) and the covering of mares is treated as ‘work carried out on goods’.”

New Form 64-8 agent authorisation

By   29 March 2022
0

New 64-8 agent authorisation form

HMRC has issued a notice which states that, from 31 March 2022, businesses taking on new clients will need them to complete a new form 64-8 to give authorisation for them to deal with HMRC on their client’s behalf.

Existing clients do not need to re-authorise their current relationship.

Access

The new form will be available from 31 March 2022 and may be downloaded by searching for “Tax agents and advisers; authorising your agent” on GOV.UK. There is no direct link yet.

The new form is said to improve data protection and allows taxpayers to state which tax regime they want you to access. The form also includes new guidance for taxpayers and what data they are agreeing to share with their agent.

VAT: Mind the gap

By   28 March 2022
0

HMRC has published details of the VAT gap for 2020 – 2021.

The VAT Gap

The VAT gap is measured by comparing the net VAT total theoretical liability with tax actually paid. This is comparing the amount of VAT HMRC expected to receive in the UK and the VAT HMRC actually received.

The figures

The net VAT theoretical liability £129 billion

Net VAT received £101.7 billion

Net VAT receipts related to net VAT total theoretical liability £120.4 billion

VAT gap £8.6 billion

The VAT gap is therefore 6.7%.

Notes

The 2020 to 2021 net receipts figure in the VAT gap includes an adjustment for payments that were deferred in 2020 under the VAT Payments Deferral Scheme in response to Covid-19. They also reflect reduced VAT rates for the hospitality sector, holiday accommodation and attractions, and zero rate for personal protective equipment.

Methodology

Information on the method used to estimate the VAT gap is here for those interested (I don’t imagine that there will be that many…).

Reduction

The estimate of the VAT gap for 2020 to 2021 £8.6 billion shows a reduction compared with the estimate of the VAT gap for 2019 to 2020 which was £12.3 billion.

Previous year’s VAT gap figures for comparison here.

This seems to be an awful amount of tax which has “gone missing”.