Category Archives: Law

VAT: Is the supply of football pitches an exempt right over land? The Netbusters case.

By Marcus Ward 11 November 2020

Latest from the courts.

In the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) case of Netbusters (UK) Limited the issue was whether the supply was the standard rated provision of sporting facilities, or an exempt right over land.

Background

Netbusters organised football and netball leagues and provided the playing facilities (artificial pitches for football and courts for netball). The hire of the facilities was for a defined period of time and no other party had the right to access the pitches during those times. The hire could be a block, or one-off booking. The appellant contended that the supplies were exempt via VAT Act 1994, Sch 9, Group 1 – “The grant of any interest in or right over land or of any licence to occupy land…” However, item 1 Note (para m) excludes the “the grant of facilities for playing any sport or participating in any physical recreation” in which case they become standard rated. To add complexity, Note 16 overrides the exception for sporting facilities (so they are exempt) if the grant of the facilities is for:

“(a) a continuous period of use exceeding 24 hours; or
(b) a series of 10 or more periods, whether or not exceeding 24 hours in total, where the following conditions are satisfied—
(i) each period is in respect of the same activity carried on at the same place;
(ii) the interval between each period is not less than one day and not more than 14 days;
(iii) consideration is payable by reference to the whole series and is evidenced by written agreement;
(iv) the grantee has exclusive use of the facilities; and
(v) the grantee is a school, a club, an association or an organisation representing affiliated clubs or constituent associations.”

I have a simplified flowchart which may assist if you, or your clients, need to look at these types of supplies further.

Another issue was whether Netbusters’ league/tournament management services which were, in principle, available independently of pitch hire, but in practice rarely were provided in that way, were separate supplies or composite. There was a single price payable for both pitch hire and league management services.

The appellant contended that its supplies were exempt via VAT Act 1994, Sch 9, Group 1 or that Revenue and Customs Brief 8 (2014): sports leagues, is applicable which states “HMRC accepts that the decision of the FTT is applicable to all traders who operate in circumstances akin to Goals Soccer Centres plc. This includes traders who hire the pitches from third parties such as local authorities, schools and clubs…”

HMRC argued that there was no intention to create a tenancy and the agreements between the parties did not provide for exclusive use of the premises, so the supplies fell to be standard rated.

Decision

The appeal was allowed; the supply was a singe exempt supply because the objective character of the supplies were properly categorised as the granting of interests in, rights over or licenses to occupy land. It was found to be significant Netbusters (or its customers) had the ability to exclude others from the pitches during the period of the matches.

It was therefore unnecessary to consider whether Netbusters’ supplies grants of facilities satisfy all the conditions set out in Note 16 (although the FTT were disinclined to do this anyway as a consequence of the way respondent prepared its case).

Commentary

The issue of the nature sporting rights has a long and acrimonious history both in the UK and EU courts. Any business providing similar services are advised to review the VAT treatment applied.

VAT: Check UK trade tariffs from 1 January 2021

By Marcus Ward 6 November 2020

HMRC has published information on Tariffs.

You can use this service to check the UK Global Tariff that will apply to goods imported post-Brexit. It also shows the difference between what you pay now and what you’ll pay from 1 January 2021.

The UK Global Tariff will apply to all goods imported from 1 January 2021 – which will include bringing in goods from EU Member States. (currently acquisitions, not imports).

VAT: Education and catering – University Of Southampton Students’ Union case

By Marcus Ward 6 November 2020

Latest from the courts

In the University Of Southampton Students’ Union (USSU) First Tier Tribunal (FTT) case the issue was the VAT treatment of supplies of hot food and coffee; whether the appellant was an eligible institution making principal supplies of education or vocational training and/or whether supplies of hot food and coffee closely related to such principal supplies.

Background

USSU argued that both the supply of hot food and coffee by the USSU shop are exempt via The VAT Act 1994 Schedule 9, group 6, Item 4(a) and note 1(e) as supplies made by an eligible body which makes principal supplies of vocational training, and which are closely related to the (exempt) principal supply of education by the University of Southampton or vocational training by USSU. In the alternative, exemption applies for matters closely related to supplies of education by a third party via a published HMRC concession (and its supplies were within HMRC’s conditions for such a concession).

HMRC disagreed and claimed that these supplies were not closely related to education and that USSU was not an eligible body (no ring fencing of the profits such that they were not necessarily reinvested in its own supplies of education). Therefore, the supplies were properly taxable, and they declined to pay the appellant’s claim of overpaid output tax. The respondent also cited the Loughborough Students’ UnionUpper Tribunal (UT) case.

Decision

The appeal was dismissed for the following reasons:

USSU did not satisfy the definition of vocational training
the supplies of hot food and coffee were not closely related to a supply of education or vocational training
USSU did not satisfy the definition of an “eligible body”

Commentary

Superficially, the claim seemed good. Para 5.5 of PN 709/1 states: “If you’re a student union and you’re supplying catering (including hot takeaway food) to students both on behalf, and with the agreement, of the parent institution, as a concession you can treat your supplies in the same way as the parent institution itself. This means that you can treat your supplies as exempt when made by unions at universities.. This means that most supplies of food and drink made by the union, where the food is sold for consumption in the course of catering will be exempt… For example, food and drink sold from canteens, refectories and other catering outlets (excluding bars), plus food and drink sold from vending machines situated in canteens and similar areas.”

However, the Notice then goes on to add “But it does not cover food and drink sold from campus shops, bars, tuck shops, other similar outlets and certain vending machines…”

This appeal looks a close-run thing, but it demonstrates that small differences in detail can produce different VAT outcomes. We urge all Student Unions and other entities “attached” to education providers to review their position.

VAT: Post Brexit Import licences and certificates

By Marcus Ward 5 November 2020

From 1 January 2021 businesses importing (including bringing in from the EU which were previously acquisitions) certain goods will require licences and certificates. Additionally, there will be new rules for bringing goods into the UK. As the UK will be a third country post Brexit (third country refers to any country outside the EU, and in this case outside its economic structures – the single market and the customs union).

Licences and certificates

A business will need to obtain a licence or certificate to import some types of goods (below) into the UK and it may also need to pay an inspection fee for some goods before they’re allowed into the UK.

The Goods

The goods, with links to details, are as follows;

Further GOV.UK information on importing goods from the EU to Great Britain from 1 January 2021 here.

A VAT Did you know?

By Marcus Ward 30 October 2020

Latest from the courts.

The rolls used in Subway’s hot sandwiches are not bread. According to a recent ruling by Ireland’s Supreme Court, because of the high level of sugar in the rolls, they cannot be taxed as bread, so the VAT zero rate cannot apply.

VAT: Post Brexit UK Tariffs

By Marcus Ward 15 October 2020

Further to my recent article on the Border Operating Model, we now know what Tariffs the UK will apply.

Currently, goods are able to move from country to country inside the EU completely Tariff free. This means that there is no need for import and export formalities which add delays and red tape. Unfortunately, as a result of Brexit, from 1 January 2021, EU/UK trade will be subject to Tariffs as the UK will be a “third country” (third country refers to any country outside the EU, and in this case outside its economic structures – the single market and the customs union).

Commercially, Tariffs add to the cost of importing goods into the UK by UK businesses and increase the price of exports to overseas customers. It is not possible to reclaim the cost of Tariffs (unlike VAT) so these will always represent a real cost to a buyer. The government has now announced what the UK Tariffs will be here.

Overview

The UK has broadly retained the existing Tariff for goods brought into the EU from third countries. However, there are some changes for; important industrial components (nuts, bolts, tubes and screws etc) some consumer products, the removal of Tariffs below 2% and the rounding of Tariffs with a decimal point.

Action

Businesses should review their exposure to these tariffs and what the related customs duty burden will be. They will also need to consider; budgets, pricing and alternative business structures – which may include manufacturing in the EU rather than the UK. We also recommend reviewing Commodity Codes, values for Customs Duties and the origin of the goods. Please also note that the use of incoterms will become increasingly important.

VAT: New guidance on the border with the EU post-Brexit

By Marcus Ward 14 October 2020

This month the government have issued new guidance: The Border with the European Union Importing and Exporting Goods on the Border Operating Model. This provides comprehensive guidance on the movement of goods from 1 January 2021 and adds to previous guidance.

This is important information for any business moving goods between GB, the EU and NI and needs to be considered for tax planning and general preparation for Brexit. These rules will likely come into force regardless of whether the UK has negotiated an agreement with the EU.

The introduction comes in three stages:

Stage One – January 2021
Stage Two – April 2021
Stage Three – July 2021

Stage One

Business will need to:

understand the requirements of EU Member States. The necessary processes must have been done and documentation completed to comply with these requirements
obtain a GB EORI number to move goods to or from the UK
if undertaking any EU customs processes, businesses will need an EU EORI
importers; check which goods are on the controlled goods list- if they are on the controlled goods list, a full customs declaration is required
if importing non-controlled goods, decide whether to delay the customs declaration for up to six months or complete full customs declarations on import
decide how to complete customs formalities: Most businesses are expected to use a customs intermediary
consider obtaining a Duty Deferment Account (DDA). A DDA allows holders to delay customs duty, excise duty and import duty, to be paid once a month rather than on individual consignments
check to see if a facilitation would be of benefit. There are a number of facilitations, including the Common Transit Convention
if importing live animals or high-priority plants, business needs to be prepared for submitting additional documentation and checks taking place at point of destination
exporters; be prepared to submit customs export declarations
hauliers; be ready to use the “Check an HGV is ready” service

Stage Two

If businesses are importing Products of Animal Origin (POAO) or a regulated plant and plant product; they will need to:

to submit pre-notification and the relevant health documentation

Stage Three

Businesses must:

meet full customs requirements including submitting declarations, regardless of whether it is a controlled or a non-controlled good
pay VAT and excise duty where necessary
submit safety and security declarations
be prepared for customs compliance checks either at port or an inland site
be prepared for relevant SPS goods to enter GB via a Border Control Post either at port or an inland site, accompanied by sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) documentary requirements

General

From 1 January 2021

Customs Declarations – Importers and exporters will have to complete UK and EU customs declarations after the end of the transition period. Some locations will require pre-lodgement of customs declarations prior to the movement of goods, which will particularly affect ‘roll on-roll off’ (RoRo) movements
Customs Duties – Importers will need to ensure that any customs duties applicable to their goods under the new UK Global Tariff are paid. Importers will need to determine the origin, classification and customs value of their goods. There are options available to defer any payment that is due
VAT will be levied on imports of goods from the EU, following the same rates and structures as are applied to Rest of World (RoW) imports. VAT registered importers will be able to use postponed VAT accounting. Non-VAT registered importers have the same options available to report and pay import VAT as they do for customs duties

Businesses will need to review their processes for dealing with cross-border goods, both between the EU and Northern Ireland. This includes; customs declarations, compliance, provision of data, obtaining a duty deferment account and GB/EU EORI numbers as necessary. We also advise liaising with suppliers and customers to ensure, as far as possible, that transactions are as seamless as possible in these challenging times.

Ten Questions every business should ask about VAT

By Marcus Ward 14 October 2020

1. Am I sure that a VAT inspection would not find any errors?

An inspection can result in significant assessments, penalties and interest, apart from a business becoming “known” to HMRC. Peace of mind is a valuable benefit for a business owner too!

2. Am I sure that I am reclaiming as much VAT as possible?

We often find that businesses miss out on recovering input tax, this clearly results in an actual cost.

3. Do I take full advantage all available VAT reliefs, customs exemptions and duty refund schemes?

Failure to do so will create a tax cost and may be putting a business in a less competitive position.

4. Am I up to date on the indirect tax developments in my key markets?

Indirect tax changes rapidly, and so does the market place. Being unaware of changes that affect you may result in VAT being overpaid, or penalties being levied if you have underdeclared tax. It may also put you at a competitive disadvantage.

5. Have I considered the impact of tax rate changes on my pricing and margin, and have I taken the necessary measures?

Budgeting is affected by VAT. Failure to consider indirect taxes may eat into profit.

6. Do I collect all the data about my customers and transactions that could be required by tax authorities?

As in many VAT circumstances, getting it wrong or missing something results in penalties.

7. Do I comply with all indirect tax requirements in the jurisdictions where I operate or where my customers belong?

VAT and GST does exist outside the UK and ignoring overseas indirect tax obligations may result in action being taken by foreign authorities which will prove to be very uncomfortable and expensive. It is important to understand the rules for indirect tax in each country/area you trade. Don’t get caught out.

8. Do I have the tools to analyse my indirect tax flows and data?

Allocating sufficient technical and human resources to VAT is important. Seeking professional advice at the appropriate time is also prudent.

9. Could changes in the way my business is structured or how transactions are organised improve my indirect tax position and/or reduce complexity?

Saving money and reducing tax complications must be near the top of every business’ wish list. Seeking professional advice on structuring a business or a transaction goes a long way to achieving this

10. Is my business using the right VAT scheme?

There are many special schemes that a business may use, from the Flat Rate Scheme to Margin Schemes. Most are optional, but some, like the Tour Operators’ Margin Scheme are compulsory. Choose the wrong one, or being unaware of a beneficial scheme could cost.

It is important to constantly monitor a business’ VAT position. The nature of trade changes, technology changes, case law changes and the VAT rules are constantly in a state of flux. It is easy to assume that everything is alright because it has always been done that way, but there may be significant exposures and missed opportunities out there. Things will also change once the terms of Brexit have been agreed (or not). We offer services from a basic healthcheck to a full technical review. A review will let you rest easy in your bed if nothing else!

VAT: New HMRC guidance for businesses trading with the EU

By Marcus Ward 1 October 2020

HMRC has produced some help for business which will trade with other EU Member States from 1 January 2021 after Brexit. This includes videos and other information. it is divided into the following categories:

The guidance sets out what a business needs to do if it:

exports goods to the EU (currently called dispatches)
imports goods from the EU (currently called acquisitions)
moves people, data and services between the UK and the EU

It is said that the videos (on You Tube) are to help a business understand more about the decisions and processes in dealing with other countries. The actions will be required regardless of the outcome of negotiations with the EU and whether or not the government secures a Free Trade Agreement.

VAT: Are aphrodisiac products food? – The X case

By Marcus Ward 1 October 2020

Latest from the courts

Can products designed to, errr… stimulate sexual desire be treated as foodstuffs? – Only in VAT do such questions ahem arise eh?

Background

X (the name of the business), sold items in its sex shop which included; capsules, drops, powders and sprays presented as aphrodisiacs that stimulate libido. Those products, which are composed essentially of elements of animal or vegetable origin, were intended for human consumption and were to be taken orally.

X applied the reduced rate to these products (the rate in The Netherlands, certain food in the UK is zero rated) treating the sexual stimulants as foodstuffs.

This was challenged by the tax authorities as it was not considered that they fell within the definitions of ‘foodstuffs for human consumption’. Assessments were issued for the difference between the reduced rate and the standard rate. The case was referred to the ECJ – C-331/19 Staatssecretaris van Financiën vs X

The Gerechtshof den Haag (Court of Appeal, The Hague, Netherlands) found in favour of X, ruling that the use of the products in question as aphrodisiacs did not preclude them from being taxed at the reduced rate applicable to foodstuffs. This was broadly on the basis that the products were intended to be consumed orally and were made from ingredients that may be found in foodstuffs.

The VAT Directive contains no definition of the concepts of ‘foodstuffs for human consumption’ or ‘products normally used to supplement foodstuffs or as a substitute for foodstuffs, so that is, at the least, unhelpful, although it was emphasised that the words must be interpreted in accordance with the usual meaning of them in everyday language.

Decision

It was ruled that any product intended for human consumption which provides the human body with the nutrients necessary to keep the human body alive and enable it to function and develop comes within the scope of the category set out in point 1 of Annex III to the VAT Directive, even if the consumption of that product also aims to produce other effects.

Further; the nutritional role was a decisive factor for a product to be classed as a ‘foodstuff for human consumption’/ The question whether that product has health benefits, its ingestion entails a certain pleasure for the consumer, or its use is part of a certain social context, is irrelevant. Consequently, the fact that consumption of that product has positive effects on the libido of the person ingesting it is irrelevant.

So, aphrodisiacs can be food.

Action

If any business which sell such products which, incidentally, contain nutrients may have a VAT claim based on this case.