Category Archives: Start Up

VAT: Education and Health & Welfare – new HMRC guidance

By   23 August 2022
0

The subject of education often gives rise to complex VAT issues – as the number of Tribunal cases illustrates.

Background

A number of schools provide early or pre-school education (before compulsory education). All children aged four should be able to access an early education place and some early education and childcare services offer free part-time early or pre-school education to three year olds. This is paid for at the discretion of Local Authorities. Places for children under three in voluntary or private pre-school settings are paid for mainly by parents.

Update

In light of, inter alia, the Yarburgh Children’s Trust, Wakefield College , Longbridge and St Paul’s Community Project, HMRC has updated to reflect changes to it’s policy in respect of charities supplying; crèche, pre-school education, nursery, after-school clubs and playgroup facilities.

Business test

HMRC’s past position was that if a charity supplied nursery and crèche facilities for a consideration that was fixed at a level designed to only cover its costs, this was not a business activity for VAT purposes. Now the two-part test derived from the Wakefield College Court of Appeal case will be applied:

  • Test One

The activity results in a supply of goods or services for consideration. This requires a legal relationship between the supplier and the recipient. The initial question is whether the supply is made for a consideration. An activity that does not involve the making of supplies for consideration is not a business activity.

  • Test Two

The supply is made for the purpose of obtaining income therefrom (remuneration)

General

The provision of pre-school education (without charge) is non-business; breakfast clubs and after-school child-minding/homework clubs remain non-business in the Local Authority sector even when a charge is made. This is on condition that the school offers the service strictly to its own pupils and that the fee charged is designed to no more than cover overhead costs.

Law

VAT Act 1994, Schedule 9, Group 6 – Education

VAT Act 1994, Schedule 9, Group 7, Item 9 – Health and Welfare

VAT & Customs Duty: Goodbye CHIEF, hello CDS

By   23 August 2022
0

Businesses who import into the UK currently use Customs Handling of Import and Export Freight (CHIEF) to declare goods.

There is also a separate scheme running concurrently, known as Customs Declaration Service (CDS).

From 1 October 2022 CHIEF will cease and importers must use CDS.

Exports

CHIEF is also currently used for exports and this will continue to a later date of: 31 March 2023.

Action

This change will significantly affect all businesses which import goods. Although it is likely that import agents will handle the majority of issues, an importer will be required to:

Failure to comply with these requirements will result in a business being unable to import goods.

VAT: Making Tax Digital (MTD) Reminder

By   23 August 2022
0

HMRC has issued a reminder that:

  • from 1 November 2022, taxpayers will no longer be able to use their existing VAT online account to file their monthly or quarterly VAT returns
  • taxpayers that file annual VAT returns will still be able to use their VAT online account until 15 May 2023
  • by law, VAT-registered businesses must now sign up to MTD and use MTD-compatible software to keep their VAT records and file their VAT returns
  • there are penalties for businesses that do not sign up for MTD and file their VAT returns through MTD-compatible software,
  • even if taxpayers already use MTD-compatible software to keep records and file their VAT returns online, they must sign up to MTD before they file their next return
  • businesses may be able to get a discount on software through the UK Government’s Help to Grow: Digital scheme, which offers 50% off compatible digital accounting software

VAT: No invoice – no claim. The Tower Bridge GP Ltd case

By   9 August 2022
0

Latest from the courts

In the Court of Appeal (CoA) case of Tower Bridge GP Ltd the issue was whether the appellant could claim input tax in a situation where it did not (and does not) hold a valid tax invoice.

Background

Tower Bridge was the representative member of a VAT group which contained Cantor Fitzgerald Europe Ltd (CFE). CFE traded in carbon credits. These carbon credit transactions were connected to VAT fraud.

The First Tier Tribunal (FTT) found that CFE neither knew, nor should have known, that the transactions it entered into before 15 June 2009 were connected to VAT fraud but that it should have known that its transactions were connected to fraud from 15 June 2009. The appeal relates only to transactions entered into before that date.

CFE purchased carbon credits from Stratex Alliance Limited (“Stratex”) The carbon credits supplied to CFE were to be used by the business for the purpose of its own onward taxable transactions (in carbon credits). The total of VAT involved was £5,605,119.74.

The Stratex invoices were not valid VAT invoices. They did not show a VAT registration number for Stratex, nor did they name CFE as the customer. Although Stratex was a taxable person, it transpired that Stratex was not registered for VAT (and therefore could not include a valid VAT number on its invoices) and that it fraudulently defaulted on its obligation to account to HMRC for the sums charged as output tax on these invoices.

Subsequent investigations by HMRC resulted in Stratex not being able to be traced.

Contentions

The appellant contended that it is entitled to make the deduction either as of right, or because HMRC unlawfully refused to use its discretion to allow the claim by accepting alternative evidence.

HMRC denied Tower Bridge the recovery of the input tax on the Stratex invoices on the basis that the invoices did not meet the formal legal requirements to be valid VAT invoices. HMRC also refused to exercise their discretion to allow recovery of the input tax on the basis that:

  • Stratex was not registered for VAT
  • the transactions were connected to fraud
  • CFE failed to conduct reasonable due diligence in relation to the transactions

Decision

Dismissing this appeal, the CoA ruled that where an invoice does not contain the information required by legislation (The Value Added Tax Regulations 1995 No 2518 Part III, Regulation 14), or contains an error in that information, which is incapable of correction, the right to deduct cannot be exercised. The appellant did not have the ability to make a claim as of right.

The Court then considered whether HMRC ought to have permitted Tower Bridge to make a claim using alternative evidence. It found that the attack on HMRC’s exercise of discretion fails for the reasons contended by HMRC (above). These were perfectly legitimate matters for HMRC to take into account in deciding whether to exercise the first discretion in the taxable person’s favour.

CFE had failed to carry out “the most basic of checks on Stratex”.

So, the appeal was dismissed.

Commentary

This was hardly a surprising outcome considering that if an exception were to be made, there would be a loss to the public purse consisting of the input tax, with no corresponding gain to the public purse from the output tax that Stratex ought to have paid, but fraudulently did not.

This case demonstrates the importance of obtaining a proper tax invoice and to carry out checks on its validity. Additionally, there is a need to conduct accurate due diligence on the supply chain. I have summarised the importance of Care with input tax claims which includes a helpful list of checks which must be carried out.

VAT & Customs Duty – Valuation for import purposes

By   5 August 2022
0

Methods of calculating import value

There are six methods for calculating the value of imported goods to assess the amount of Customs Duty and import VAT a business to pay. The same value is also used for trade statistics.

All six methods are outlined below and should be tried in order. If Method 1 does not apply, try Method 2. If that does not apply, try 3 and so on. However, Method 5 can be tried before 4.

Method 1

The transaction value – the price payable to the seller. This is the most common valuation and is used in most cases.

Try Method 2 if there has been no sale of goods.

Method 2

The customs value of identical goods, produced in the same country as the imports.

Try Method 3 if there are no identical goods.

Method 3

The customs value of similar goods, which must be:

  • produced in the same country
  • able to carry out the same tasks and be
  • commercially interchangeable

Try Method 4 if there are no similar goods.

Method 4

The selling price of the goods (or identical or similar goods) in the UK.

Try Method 5 if there are no UK sales of the goods.

Method 5

The production cost of the goods, including the cost of any materials, manufacturing and any other processing used in production.

Try Method 6 if this production cost information is unavailable.

Method 6

Reasonably adapting one of the previous methods to fit unusual circumstances.

Legislation

In the UK valuation is covered by the Taxation (Cross-border Trade) Act 2018 & The Customs (Import Duty) (EU Exit) Regulations 2018 and The VAT Act 1994, Section 19.

What to include in the Method 1 calculation

If they are not already included in the seller’s price, the importer must add the costs of:

  • delivery to the EU border
  • most commissions (except buying commission)
  • royalties and licence fees paid by you on the imported goods as a condition of sale
  • containers and packing
  • any proceeds of resale the seller will receive
  • goods and services you provide to the seller for free or at a reduced cost – eg components incorporated in the imported goods, or development and design work carried out outside the EU and necessary for the production of the imports

If you import goods from a processor – ie a business that assembles or otherwise works on one or more sets of existing products to create your new imported products – transaction values can be built up by adding to the processing costs the value of any materials or components you provided to the processor.

What to exclude from your calculation

Items to be left out of the customs value if certain conditions are met include:

  • delivery costs within the EU
  • EU duties or taxes
  • taxes paid in the country of origin or export
  • quantity and trade discounts and those relating to cash and early settlement, that are valid at the time the goods are valued
  • dividend payments to the seller
  • marketing activities related to the imports
  • buying commission
  • export quota and licence costs
  • interest charges
  • rights of reproduction
  • post-importation work, eg construction or assembly
  • management fees

Further details here.

VAT – Business Entertainment. What input tax may I recover?

By   4 August 2022
0

VAT – Recovery of input tax incurred on entertainment – Flowchart

One of the most common questions asked on “day-to-day” VAT is whether input tax incurred on entertainment is claimable.  The answer to this seemingly straightforward question has become increasingly complex as a result of; HMRC policy, EU involvement and case law.

Different rules apply to entertaining; clients, contacts, staff, partners and directors depending on the circumstances.  It seems reasonable to treat entertaining costs as a valid business expense.  After all, a business, amongst other things, aims to increase sales and reduce costs as a result of these meetings.  However, HMRC sees things differently and there is a general block on business entertainment.  It seems like HMRC does not like watching people enjoying themselves at the government’s expense!

If, like me, you think in pictures, then a flowchart may be useful for deciding whether to claim entertainment VAT.  It covers all scenarios, but if you have a unique set of circumstances or require assistance with some of the definitions, please contact me.

VAT -Business Entertainment Flowchart

Download here: VAT Business Entertainment Input tax recovery flowchart

VAT: Where’s my reply?!

By   21 July 2022
0

HMRC has launched a new service dashboard which aims to let taxpayers who have written to HMRC know when to expect a reply.

This sounds like a significant development and a very helpful tool for taxpayers and advisers alike. However…

it only covers applications for registration, deregistration and group registration – and only those made by post.

Any other checks are met with a screen stating “You need to use another service to get an update”.

So, a small step in the right direction.

VAT: Updated guidance – Non-Statutory Clearances Service

By   21 July 2022
0

HMRC has published new guidance on the non-statutory clearance service available for all businesses and their advisers.

Non-Statutory clearances

A Non-Statutory clearance is a mechanism where a person can ask HMRC in writing for guidance or advice in certain circumstances. The guidance sets out how to use this procedure. The service is limited, however, and HMRC will only advise if the applicant:

  • has fully read the relevant guidance or contacted the relevant helpline
  • has not been able to find the information required
  • is uncertain about HMRC’s interpretation of tax legislation

However, HMRC will not respond if

  • it is not given all the necessary information —checklists at Annex D (for VAT) provide details of what is required
  • it does not think that there are genuine points of uncertainty – it will explain why HMRC think this and direct the applicant to the relevant online guidance
  • if  HMRC think the clearance request is to give tax planning advice, or to approve tax planning products or arrangements
  • the application is about treatment of transactions which, in HMRC’s view, are for the purposes of avoiding tax
  • HMRC is checking the applicant’s position for the period in question, in which case queries must be directed to the officer dealing with the inspection
  • it is a clearance on matters of fact, such as if certain activities constitute a business
  • there is a statutory clearance applicable to the relevant transaction

HMRC is currently not dealing with postal applications, so a request must be sent by email to nonstatutoryclearanceteam.hmrc@hmrc.gov.uk

HMRC will usually reply within 28 days, but say where difficult or complicated issues are involved it may take longer. If this is the case, HMRC will acknowledge a request and tell the applicant when they can expect a full reply. VAT non-statutory clearance requests are currently taking around 12 weeks to process.

Appeal

There is no general right of appeal against advice given by HMRC, except where rights to appeal are set out in statute.

Appeal rights are usually against decisions HMRC take, such as issuing an assessment for underpaid tax or a penalty.

However, some VAT related decisions are classed as ‘appealable decisions’ by statute. The letter HMRC sends will explain if the applicant is able to appeal and what to do if the applicant disagrees with a VAT decision.

Relying on HMRC advice

There has been changes to such reliance, set out here. HMRC explain when its advice is not binding here.

VAT: New tool to check HMRC’s performance and service levels

By   21 July 2022
0

Via this service dashboard you can check current processing times and service levels for post and online requests.

The guidance sets current performance and service levels, processing dates and the date HMRC aims to return to normal service levels where there is a delay.

It currently advises:

VAT registration

Normal Service – HMRC aim to reply within 30 working days from the date the request was sent.

VAT deregistration

Normal service – HMRC aim to reply within 30 working days from the date the request was sent.

VAT – group registration application

Delayed Service

HMRC aim to return to normal service of 30 working days by the end of August 2022.

This date is an estimate and may change. HMRC say that it is sorry for the delay.

HMRC is currently processing requests received on 17 March 2022.

If you sent your request after 24 June 2022, please do not contact HMRC as it has not been processed yet.

VAT – option to tax

Delayed Service

HMRC aim to return to normal service of 30 working days by the end of August 2022.

This date is an estimate and may change. Again, HMRC say that it is sorry for the delay.

HMRC is currently processing requests received on 9 December 2021.

If you sent your request after 9 December 2021, please do not contact HMRC as it has not been processed yet.

Further, you can Check when you can expect a reply from HMRC