Reports that a recently issued EC consultation document is proposing to harmonise VAT rates across Europe thus removing the UK’s zero rate have stirred up something of a hornet’s nest. Clearly, in this delicate (although slowly improving) climate for house builders an additional 20% cost could damage the market irrevocably adding £50,000 to the cost of a £250,000 house. Commentators in the trade have announced that it would be a disaster for new home buyers, the construction sector, and the UK economy in general.
However, are these reports in the national press all that they seem? Or is this another tabloid attack on the EC? Such consultation documents are issued regularly and they consider many aspects of VAT across the EC. An EC spokesman, when questioned about this issue, stated “the consultation was not pre-empting a move and considering VAT ‘in general’” Additionally, a spokesman for the Treasury announced “’The UK government has no intention of agreeing to such a proposal, and there is no consultation to change the zero tax rate”. Historically, UK authorities have fought doggedly to retain all of the UK’s zero rates because once they are removed, it is not possible under EC legislation, to reinstate them. The UK is unique in applying the zero rate to items such as food, new houses, books and newspapers and while it is not possible to widen or extend the scope of the zero rating, the UK is permitted, for the time being, to retain those which are in place. So, is there any truth in these “rumours”? It appears that the report was published by the Daily Mail, which in turn appears to have obtained the story from The Daily Express. Although there is a continuing will to harmonise VAT across the EC, I would be very surprised indeed if the UK was to be forced to standard rate new house builds. My personal view is that there appears to be a little mischief making here and the house building industry has enough to worry about rather than this imposed 20% price hike.
Please see here for our land and property services