Tag Archives: brexit

VAT and Customs Duty: Brexit latest

By Marcus Ward 20 August 2019

HMRC has been issuing guidance in readiness for Brexit, and in particular, a No Deal Brexit.

They generally provide information on preparations and actions required by business that trade cross-border.

Imports

If a business bring goods into the UK from the EU there are actions you should take before and after you’ve imported the goods. This applies to:

importers
freight forwarders
fast parcel operators
customs agents
traders who move their own goods

(This guidance does not apply to moving goods between Ireland and Northern Ireland). A border on the island of Ireland is a whole other matter.

The full guidance for importers.

Exports

Again, this guidance relates to:

exporters
freight forwarders
fast parcel operators
customs agents
traders who move their own goods.

The full guidance for exporters.

Email updates on Brexit

We recommend that business falling within the above definitions sign up the free HMRC Brexit email alert service.

This service covers: information about Brexit including the Article 50 process, negotiations, and announcements about policy changes as a result of Brexit.

It is crucial that businesses understand the impact of a No Deal Brexit and make preparations for all eventualities of the political negotiations. Sign up here

VAT: Brexit – Retail Export Scheme benefits

By Marcus Ward 2 August 2019

VAT free shopping for all! Save 20% on anything you buy!

This seems very unlikely I hear you mutter, but, but…..

If you live in the UK after a No Deal Brexit, there is a simple way of never paying VAT on any retail purchases for your own use. From a piano to a gymnasium, from a teapot to a lawnmower – all may be purchased completely VAT free and legally. It does not appear that the Government has considered this, it certainly does not feature in the recent report on the “Alternative Arrangements”. This is especially relevant to the Northern Ireland/Republic of Ireland land border. It may be that if we believe hard enough in Brexit we can avoid UK residents not paying UK VAT…

So how will this fabulous shopping opportunity come into being?

There is an EU-wide system (set out at Article 131 of The Principle VAT Directive) which provides for the recovery of VAT incurred by individuals from outside the EU. Clearly, after a No-Deal Brexit, that will be anyone in the UK. This is called the Retail Export Scheme (RES). After a hard Brexit, any goods moving from an EU Member State into the UK will now be classed as exports (pre-Brexit there is free movement of goods within the EU, so there would be no exports when goods move cross-border within the EU).

How does RES work?

When an individual buys goods in an EU Member State and exports them for his/her personal use, the retailer will charge VAT at the rate applicable in that country. The shop will also issue a certain document. This document is stamped when the goods are physically exported buy the buyer and the customer returns the form to the retailer. It is a quite painless procedure. When this evidence that the goods have been exported is received by the retailer, it will refund the VAT paid – The result = VAT free shopping. Also, the scheme has no minimum sales value.

And after Brexit?

The UK has said its 2017 Customs Bill that VAT will not be charged on personal imports. This is effectively inviting tax free cross-border shopping and consequently, logically, reducing retails sales in the UK. I am sure that that is not what the Government had in mind. It is likely that there could be wide scale use of RES. After all, what is a bit of paperwork and a short drive to save 20%?! This is even before one considers the abuse of the arrangements, which, with the obvious financial benefits, could be significant. A day trip to mainland Europe will be very inviting, and then, there is our land border…

Some politics…

The Irish border

Clearly, the most relevant issue is the Irish border. Regardless of the political noises, there will be a “difference” between EU and “third country” (which the UK will be after a No Deal Brexit) rules between the two countries. These differences facilitate the use of the RES. There is nothing in any proposals which will prevent cross-border shopping on the island of Ireland. I can imagine retailers in Dublin rubbing their hands together while those in Belfast gloomily survey empty shops. Perhaps new retailers will pop up on the Irish side of the EU/UK divide to make matters even more helpful for bargain hunting shoppers from the UK. Another issue which I doubt the UK has considered is that if there is no border (which we are told by the Government will happen even though a No-Deal Brexit will definitively and specifically not permit this) there will be nobody to stamp the forms. I won’t get into the politics of the Good Friday Agreement (GFA) and a No Deal Brexit, but it seems almost certain that there will have to be a deal with the EU to ensure there is no border, OR the UK must renege on the GFA which could bring terrifying consequences to peace in the area, amongst a lot of other issues. What a mess.

Importance of a border with the EU

No two countries outside of the EU have ever removed border checks between themselves. They try to streamline checks where possible, as everybody wants smooth trade, but always retain border checks. Why? Simply, for goods trade, a border post is the only place where you can guarantee to have the vehicle, the items definitely being transported, and all relevant paperwork in one place. You can and do make other checks, but the border is at the core. One of the reasons for the EU legal and regulatory framework is to be able to trust that goods trade between members can take place without border checks. This means common tariffs, common rules, and legal redress. Without being a part of the regulations, there can be no such trust and a hard border is necessary.

Unsurprisingly, there have been no studies on the cost to UK retailers, and apparently, no recognition whatsoever, that this could be a serious issue. Given the political issues with the Irish border, and the serious consequences of going against the GFA, this is another issue which has been either; overlooked, dismissed, politically ignored, or relegated to the bottom of a list of so many issues caused by an ill-considered No Deal Brexit.

What the government has continually, apparently deliberately, failed to recognise is that there is no fudge that provides both freedom from EU rules and frictionless trade with a No Deal Brexit. There is no current way to reconcile Northern Ireland remaining aligned with the UK, Ireland staying fully in the EU, pure Brexit, and no border checks. Tax is simply one area in the commercial world which has been ignored, for political reasons. VAT is just one area of tax, and the RES is just one area of VAT.

HMRC VAT Helpline failures

By Marcus Ward 5 July 2019

If any of you have had the unfortunate necessity to use the VAT Helpline you will know the frustration, unhelpfulness and general exasperation of trying to get a reasonable response from the department. Well, it isn’t just you.

In correspondence between the Chair of the Treasury Select Committee and the Chief Executive and Permanent Secretary of HMRC here the previously highlighted issue of the deterioration of the performance of the HMRC VAT Helpline is addressed.

The extremely poor performance is ascribed, by the Chartered Institute of Taxation (CIOT) to:

the lack of an adequate pilot for the roll-out of Making Tax Digital (MTD) – details here
the pressures of Brexit on HMRC resources.

And HMRC state that:

their telephony performance has been impacted by ongoing recruitment and staffing shortfalls
recruitment for a no deal EU exit was slower than expected
they had to divert resources from usual business to issues with a No-Deal Brexit
the target of five minutes waiting time for the VAT Helpline has not been met
they are developing a new way of measuring performance
there are issues with some MTD businesses experiencing problems with paying VAT by direct debit

An annex to the letter, providing VAT call data from January to May 2019, shows

helpline demand increased by over 40% between January and May but the number of calls answered fell over this period
in May, HMRC answered less than 42% of the calls which made it beyond their recorded messages, compared to 72% in January
average speed of answer for those calls which were answered rose from around seven minutes in January to more than 16 minutes in May (in addition to the time spent navigating the initial recorded messages)
of the calls answered, the proportion which were answered within ten minutes fell from 64% in January to just 9% in May

Commentary

It is appreciated that some of the excuses are “reasonable” (to use HMRC parlance) and matters are not within HMRC’s influence, however, the service provided is, frankly, unacceptable. Businesses need HMRC assistance for all sorts of reasons and if it is not forthcoming, errors may be made resulting in potential penalties and interest, loss of income, deals failing, accounting compromised and uncertainty and complexity, VAT becoming a cost, and customers lost.

It is not as though HMRC have not been warned about pushing MTD through without adequate testing of systems and software at a time when Brexit was always going to make huge demands of the department. The House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee published a damning report last year here which recommended delaying the introduction of MTD. Also, the CIOT has consistently warned of the risks of implementing MTD for VAT at the same time as Brexit.

Support for business and tax agents is sadly very lacking and it appears that insufficient resources have been devoted to this. There has been an overall lack of planning, combined with a political will to push ahead with MTD regardless. It really is not good enough. And we are not even yet through the implementation of MTD for VAT with larger and more complex business yet to join the fray. That, added to the fact that many glitches have already been identified, does not give any reason to be optimistic about the future for either MTD or the VAT Helpline.

As CIOT say: while HMRC have the scale to move resources within its organisation, that is a luxury that most businesses do not enjoy.

VAT: Brexit – Intending Trader registration for overseas businesses

By Marcus Ward 14 June 2019

With the continuing uncertainty over a No-Deal Brexit, which appears to be a more likely prospect given recent political events, HMRC has made a statement on the process of registering non-UK EU businesses as intending traders in the UK.

Background

What is an intending trader?

An intending trader is a person who, on the date of the registration request:

is carrying on a business
has not started making taxable supplies
has an intention to make taxable supplies in the future

If the business satisfies HMRC of its intention, HMRC must VAT register it. VAT Act 1994, Schedule 1, 9 (b). It is, in some cases, difficult to convince that there is a genuine intention to make taxable supplies. This often comes down to documentary evidence.

Why do overseas businesses need to register as intending traders?

In the event of a No-deal Brexit, it is assumed that the EU VAT simplification that relieves the current obligation to be registered in the UK will no longer available. As a consequence, the EU supplier will itself become responsible for accounting for VAT on sales deemed to be made in the UK. In order to do this, the business will require a UK VAT registration. As the simplification is in place until Brexit, the registration will be required the very day after the UK leaves the EU – currently 1 November 2019.

Therefore, many EU businesses have applied for UK VAT registration as intending traders. That is, they do not currently make supplies, but intend to in the future (from 1 November 2109).

The issue

The Chartered Institute of Taxation has reported that businesses applying for intending trader registrations are experiencing difficulties with the process.

In response, HMRC have stated:

“Businesses in the position you have described can register for VAT using the Advanced Notification facility, by registering online requesting a voluntary registration from an advanced date of 1 November 2019. In the ‘business activity’ section they should enter trade class/SIC code 99000 European Community. In the free text box they should describe accurately what the business does and ensure there is a positive amount entered in the ‘taxable turnover in the next 12 months’ box. If this is not done the application will be rejected. This information will enable the VAT Registration Team (VRT) to identify and actively manage any registration that is conditional on the UK leaving the EU without a deal.

If there is a change to the date of withdrawal from the EU, the VRT will amend the Advanced Notification date to match this new date. If the UK enters a transitional period or agrees a deal with the EU that allows current arrangements to continue then the registration will be cancelled. The approval of an Advanced Notification registration in these circumstances is only made as a contingency for the UK leaving the EU without a deal and the VAT number may not be used unless that happens. The business will receive an automated notification of an Advanced Notification VAT Registration and the VRT may follow this up with a manual letter to further explain the conditions and both.

With the UK having agreed an extension to the date of withdrawal from the EU, we would not expect businesses to use this facility until closer to the 1st November.”

It is clearly prudent for overseas businesses which make certain supplies in the UK to properly prepare for a No-Deal Brexit. However, experience insists that many have not identified or made provisions for this outcome.

We are able to assist and advise other EU Member State businesses on this process.

Changes to recovery of VAT on imports

By Marcus Ward 15 April 2019

HMRC have recently issued RCB 2 (2019) which sets out HMRC’s view on Toll Manufacturers (TM). TM is an arrangement in which a company which has a specialised equipment processes raw materials or semi-finished goods for another company. It may also be called toll processing. Typically, a TM will import, say, pharmaceutical goods, process and distribute them within the UK for clinical trials on behalf of an overseas owner.

HMRC has become aware that a number of UK TMs have paid import VAT on behalf of overseas customers have also claimed a corresponding deduction for input tax under VAT Act 1994 Section 24. However, there is no provision in UK law for such deduction.

Current treatment

TMs will usually act as importer and recover import VAT via a C79 despite them not being the owner of the goods (the owner instructs the TM to carry out works on their goods on their behalf).

HMRC has now confirmed that this VAT treatment is incorrect, and it will no longer be permitted.

New treatment

Only the owner of the goods will be treated as the importer and be able to recover import VAT. TMs will no longer be able to claim this VAT.

However, HMRC will not require TMs to make adjustments to past claims and the treatment will only be required going forward.

Introduction

The change comes into effect from 15 July 2019

Affect

Affected TMs are likely to need to make significant changes to their systems before that date.

Overseas owners of the relevant goods will either need to:

register for UK VAT and claim the import VAT on a “regular” return, or
make a claim via the Thirteenth VAT Directive (86/560/EEC)

NB: In cases where title has passed before import into the UK (businesses sell on the goods before importing them into the UK so ownership and title has passed to the new owner, however the business that sold the goods acts as importer on UK import declarations, pays the import VAT to HMRC and receives the import VAT certificate – C79) the correct procedure is for the new owner of the goods to be the importer of record and reclaim the import VAT and not the previous owner.

As with many areas of VAT, a No-Deal Brexit is likely to increase the complications for such cross-border transactions in the future.

Please contact us if you have any queries or require assistance on this matter.

VAT: Increased input tax recovery for suppliers of financial services – Brexit

By Marcus Ward 5 April 2019

If the UK leaves the EU in a no-deal scenario there may be a benefit for UK based suppliers of financial and insurance services (so called Specified Supplies) to recipients in the EU. These Specified Supplies attract beneficial input VAT treatment pursuant to the VAT (Input Tax) (Specified Supplies) Order 1999 (the Specified Services Order).

Current position

Currently, these Specified Supplies are exempt and consequently, there is no right to deduct input tax incurred in connection with such services. However, if the Specified Supplies are provided to recipients located outside the EU, they are also VAT free, although any attributable input tax is recoverable; a good VAT position.

Post Brexit position

If the UK leaves the EU, the VAT treatment of supplies to non-EU countries is also applicable to the EU 27 countries; the EU would essentially become a “third country”.

Example

A City of London based bank supplies financial services to both Germany and the US clients. Income from these two clients is 50:50. At the current time the bank would be restricted to a claim of circa half of the VAT it incurs on expenditure in the UK. After Brexit, via The Value Added Tax (Input Tax) (Specified Supplies) (EU Exit) (No. 2) Regulations 2019 all input tax incurred will be recoverable in full.

What are Specified Supplies?

Specified Supplies are broadly:

the issue, transfer or receipt of, or any dealing with, money, any security for money or any note or order for the payment of money.
granting of credit
dealing in; shares, stocks, bonds, notes (other than promissory notes), debentures, debenture stock
the operation of any current, deposit or savings account.
the management of certain investment funds/schemes
insurance
and intermediary services in respect of the above supplies

This list is not exhaustive and is only a very general example of types of supplies which may be considered as Specified Supplies. Please seek advice on specific services.

Other matters

The government says that this change will ensure that UK businesses compete for business in the EU on an even footing with businesses in other non-EU countries.

The proposed legislation also provides that partial exemption special methods (PESM) agreed before a no-deal Brexit will be honoured so businesses will not need to apply to HMRC for approval of a new PESM. Please see guide to partial exemption here

NB: If a deal is agreed between the UK and the EU, the above legislation will not be enacted, and the current VAT treatment will continue throughout the implementation period set out in a withdrawal agreement.

VAT – EORI numbers to become invalid if No-Deal Brexit

By Marcus Ward 5 April 2019

If the UK leaves the EU on a no-deal basis, which, despite the apparent will of parliament, is still a likely outcome, all Economic Operators Registration and Identification (EORI) numbers currently used by UK VAT registered businesses will become invalid in other EU Member States.

A guide to EORI here

Businesses are obliged to use an EORI number when undertaking customs activities in the EU. Such UK businesses will be required to obtain a new EU EORI number after the date of a No-Deal Brexit. This is because if the UK leaves via a no-deal Brexit EORI numbers recorded in the UK will no longer be deemed as obtained and registered in an EU Member State. Businesses importing or exporting (currently acquiring or dispatching) from/to the EU will need to request a replacement EORI from a Member State in the EU.

The same rules will apply to businesses in the EU 27 doing business with the UK. Their EORI numbers will also be invalid and will require replacement after a no-deal Brexit date.

We understand that EORI number applications will increase immediately after Brexit and it is very likely to take significantly more time to obtain a new one. It is further probable that filing customs declarations could be disrupted, with the result that the movement of goods cross-border will be delayed.

It is possible that some Member States may be flexible in their approach to existing/new EORI numbers. However, this cannot be guaranteed and there does not appear to be any impetuous between the 27 MS to agree a common approach.

This is yet another reason, should further evidence be required, that a no-deal Brexit will have profound and long-lasting negative impact on UK business. Those who voted Leave to reduce “red tape” will become increasing surprised at the amount of additional administration required post Brexit.

VAT: Brexit referrals to CJEU

By Marcus Ward 2 April 2019

A quickie

What happens to referrals to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) after Brexit day?

Put simply, from the date the UK leaves the EU UK courts will no longer be able to refer cases to CJEU. Cases referred to CJEU before the date of leaving may still be heard.

We understand that there has been a late surge of referrals before the cut off date. This is likely to mean that there will be significant number of CJEU cases which can directly impact the UK for a time to come even though the UK is no longer a Member State.

This of course assumes that:

The UK leaves the EU
UK politicians do not actually agree some sort of compromise with the EU on this point
The Brexit date is not deferred for a long period (in which case referrals to, and decisions of, the CJEU will have direct relevance to UK VAT for many years, or even decades…).

VAT: HMRC Impact Assessment of a No-Deal Brexit

By Marcus Ward 1 April 2019

HMRC have issued an impact assessment for VAT and services if the UK leaves the EU without a deal.

The impact assessment covers the effect on businesses of amendments to existing VAT legislation and the introduction of transitional provisions for the supply of services between the UK and the EU

Summary

Under current rules:

VAT is charged on most goods and services sold within the UK and the EU
the place of supply rules for services determine the country in which a business should charge and account for VAT

If the UK leaves the EU without a deal, he UK will continue to have a VAT system. This is unsurprising as it is a major revenue raiser for the Treasury and the taxpayer is required to do all the heavy lifting the tax involves.

HMRC say the published Statutory Instruments (Sis – details of which may be found in the impact assessment but mainly The Taxation – Cross-border Trade Act 2018) broadly maintain the current VAT treatment in the event of a No-Deal Brexit. It expects that “they will have either a negligible impact on the administrative burden on businesses or no impact.”

This seems, prima facie, difficult to swallow.

HMRC also anticipate that an exception to the above is the removal of the VAT Mini One Stop Shop (MOSS), which “may have a significant ongoing cost for some EU and non-EU businesses.”

The impact assessment refers to the Economic Analysis of Brexit which makes interesting reading.

Of course, the House has voted against a No-Deal Brexit, so we can rely on that… can’t we?

VAT MOSS and No-Deal Brexit

By Marcus Ward 11 March 2019

In the event of an increasingly likely no deal Brexit, changes have been put in place to the existing MOSS (Mini One Stop Shop) arrangements. Details of MOSS here.

These intended changes will affect UK businesses which provide electronically supplied services such as cross-border telecommunication, television and radio broadcasting, or digital services to non-business (eg; individuals) recipients in the EU.

Such services include:

website hosting
supply of software
access to databases
downloading apps or music
online gaming
distance teaching

The existing threshold of £8818 pa introduced by Schedule 4A, para 15(1) of the VAT Act 1994 will be removed via SI2019/404.

This means that if there is a no deal Brexit UK businesses supplying such services will either be required to:

MOSS Non-Union Scheme

A business may use the Non-Union scheme when it supplies cross-border electronically supplied services to consumers in all EU countries (including the EU country selected as the Member State of identification).

The EU countries where a business supplies services to are known as Member States of consumption.

Selecting a member state of identification

A business must designate a Member State of identification. This can be any EU country a business chooses. A business may change the member state of identification at a later date if it wants. Again, this can be any EU country a business chooses.

Registration

A business registers online via the Member State of identification’s portal.

VAT rules

A business will be allocated a VAT number by the EU country chosen to be the Member State of identification and charge VAT at the rate of the EU countries where its customers reside. The same invoicing rules as your Member State of identification must be used (although an invoice is not required in most countries when supplying services under the MOSS scheme).

VAT returns

A business must submit detailed online quarterly VAT returns within 20 days of the end of each return period. The information is then securely transferred from your Member State of identification to the relevant Member State of consumption.

VAT rates

VAT rates can be checked for the supply of telecommunications, broadcasting and electronically supplied services using the Tax Information Communication database.

For further information and to register for MOSS please see here.