Tag Archives: construction-vat

VAT: When is the building of a house complete? (And why is it important?)

By   11 June 2019
0

Completion of a residential dwelling

A technical point which comes up surprisingly often and seems innocuous is: when is a building “complete”? The following case is helpful, and I thank Les Howard for bringing it to my attention.

The date that the construction of a dwelling is deemed to be complete is important for a number of reasons. The issue in the case of Mr and Mrs James was whether certain works could be zero rated via the VAT Act Schedule 8 Group 5 Item 2 (The supply in the course of the construction of a building designed as a dwelling…) or as HMRC contended, they were the reconstruction or alteration of an existing building and the work should be standard rated.

Background

The James used a contractor to plaster the entire interior of their house in the course of its construction. However, the work was demonstrably defective to such an extent that the James commenced legal proceedings. A surveyor advised that all of the old plaster needed to be hacked off and replaced by new plastering installed by a new firm. The stripping out and replacement works took place after the Certificate of Completion had been issued.

The James claimed input tax on the house construction via the DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme.

Technical

HMRC refused the James’ claim to have the remedial work zero-rated because, in their view, the re-plastering works amounted to the reconstruction or alteration of the house which was, when the supplies were made, an “existing building”. They proffered Note 16 of Schedule 5 which provides that “the construction of a building” does not include “(a) … the conversion, reconstruction or alteration of an existing building”.

They stated that zero-rating only applied if the work formed part of the construction of a zero-rated building. They had previously decided that the work of snagging or correction of faults carried out after the building had been completed could only be zero-rated if it was carried out by the original contractors and correction of faults formed part of the building contract. When the snagging is carried out by a different contractor, the work is to an existing building and does not qualify for zero rating.

The James stated that the Customs’ guidelines on snagging do not take into account extraordinary circumstances. Their contention was that the re-plastering works were zero rated because they had no choice but to engage the services of a different contractor other than the one who carried out the original works.

Decision

The judge found for the appellant – the re-plastering works were zero rated.

There was a query as to why The James applied for a Certificate of Completion before the plastering was completed. In nearly all cases such a certificate would crystallise the date the building was complete.

The reasons were given as:

  • the need for funds. The James could not remortgage the house without the certificate and they needed to borrow a substantial amount
  • they could not reclaim VAT under the DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme until the Certificate of Completion had been issued
  • they were aware that the building inspector was beginning to wonder why the building works were taking such a long time
  • they needed the house assessed for Council Tax which could only happen when the certificate had been issued
  • the Certificate was issued as part of the procedure required by the Building Act 1984 and the Building Regulations of 2000

These reasons were accepted by the judge.

Despite the respondents stating that:

  • for the reasons given above
  • the fact that the James had been living in the house for some time
  • they had obtained the Certificate of Completion
  • the new plastering work had been done by the new plasterer such that the house had been constructed before supply of the new plasterer’s services had been made
  • the house was an “existing building”

the judge was satisfied that in the circumstances the new plastering work was supplied in the course of the construction of the building as a dwelling house and that there was no reconstruction or alteration of an existing building in the sense contemplated by Note (16) to Group 5 Schedule 8.

He observed that the Certificate of Completion records that the substantive requirements of the Building Regulations have been satisfied. But to the naked eye the old plasterwork was obviously inadequate and dangerous ad he could not possibly consider that the construction project had finished until the new plasterwork was installed. The James’ construction project was to build a new dwelling house. Plasterwork of an acceptable standard was an integral part of the construction works. The new plasterwork was done at the earliest practicable opportunity.

Commentary

Care should be taken when considering when the completion of a house build takes place. There are time limits for DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme clams and clearly, as this case illustrates, usually work done to a house after completion does not qualify for zero rating. So, if the owner of a house is thinking of, say, building a conservatory for example, it is more prudent in VAT terms to construct it at the same time as a new house is built, and certainly before completion.

I would say that the appellant in this case achieved a surprisingly good result.

The ABC of VAT – property

By   28 May 2019
0

A glossary

Anyone who has had even the slightest brush with VAT will know that it is a very complex tax. Now, multiply that complexity by the intricacy and occasionally arcane nature of property law and one may see that the outcome will be less than straightforward. I have produced a general guide and an article on residential property VAT Triggerpoints

I hope the following glossary will help with steering through some of the difficulties.

  • Annex– a building which is joined to or is next to a larger main building usually an extension or addition to a building
  • Assign – to transfer the right or interest in a property from one party to another
  • Break clause – a clause allowing either landlord or tenant to give written notice after a particular date or period of the tenancy in order to end the tenancy
  • Beneficial owner – party deemed to make a supply of property rather than the legal owner
  • Blocked input tax – VAT which a developer is unable to recover when constructing a new dwelling. Typically, expenditure on good such as; carpets, fitted furniture, and gas and electrical appliances
  • Building materials– goods ordinarily incorporated into a property which attracts similar VAT treatment to the construction services.
  • Capital Goods Scheme(CGS) – a method of calculating the recovery amount of input tax incurred on property over a ten-year period, Details of the CGS here
  • Certificate – a document issued to a supplier in order to obtain certain zero-rated or reduced-rated building work
  • Change of number of dwellings– usually a conversion from commercial to residential, or a single house into flats (or flats into a single house) at 5% VAT
  • Consideration– a thing done or given in exchange for something else = a supply. Usually quantified in money, but in some cases non-monetary consideration
  • Construction of new dwellings – a zero rated supply
  • Contract – legal document detailing the agreement of terms between the vendor and buyer
  • Contractor – entity responsible for building works
  • Conversion–work on a non-residential building which results in a property designed as a dwelling(s) being created
  • Covenants – rules governing the property in its title deeds or lease. May impact the definition of dwellings
  • Curtilage– either a garden, or an area surrounding a building which is deemed to be part of the property
  • Designed as a dwelling– a property initially designed for residential use, regardless of any subsequent alternative use
  • Dilapidations – items that have been damaged during a tenancy for which the tenant is responsible for the cost of repair or replacement. Usually VAT free
  • DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme – a scheme which ‘self-builders’ to recover VAT on a new build dwelling or conversion. Details here
  • Dwelling– a building deemed to be residential
  • Empty house – if, in the ten years before work on a dwelling starts, it has not been lived in, the work may be subject to 5% rather than 20% VAT
  • Exempt– a supply that is VAT free. It usually results in attributable input tax falling to be irrecoverable
  • Facade– a wall (or two walls on a corner plot) which may be retained without affecting the zero rating of a new dwelling construction
  • Grant– a supply of an interest in land
  • Holiday home – the sale or long lease of a holiday home cannot be zero-rated even if it is designed as a dwelling
  • Housing Association – a non-profit organisation which rents residential property to people on low incomes or with particular needs
  • In the course of construction– meaningful works that have occurred in relation to the construction of a building (but prior to its completion)
  • Incorporated goods – goods sold with a new dwelling which are zero rated and to which the input tax block does not apply. See white goods
  • Input tax– VAT incurred on expenditure associated with property
  • Interest in, or right over, land– the right to access to and use of, land. Usually via ownership or lease
  • Lease – legal document governing the occupation by the tenant of a premises for a specific length of time
  • Licence to occupy– a permission to use land that does not amount to a tenancy
  • Live-work units – a property that combines a dwelling and commercial or industrial working space. Usually subject to apportionment
  • Major interest–a supply of a freehold interest or a lease exceeding 21 years
  • Multiple occupancy dwelling – a dwelling which is designed for occupation by persons not forming a single household
  • New building–a commercial building less than three years old the sale of which is mandatorily standard
  • Non-residential– a commercial building which is not used as a dwelling
  • Open market value – likely sale price with a willing seller and buyer, with a reasonable period of marketing and no special factors affecting the property
  • Option to tax (OTT) – act of changing the exempt sale or letting of a commercial into a taxable supply. The purpose is to either; recover input tax or avoid input tax being charged. Details here
  • OTT disapplication– the legal removal of a vendor’s option to tax
  • OTT not applicable – the OTT does not apply to residential buildings (so VAT can never apply to dwellings)
  • OTT revocation– the ability to revoke an option to tax after six months or twenty years
  • Partial exemption– a calculation to attribute input tax to exempt and taxable. Generally, VAT incurred in respect of exempt supplies is irrecoverable
  • Person constructing – a developer, contractor or sub-contractor who constructs a building
  • Premium – upfront payment for a supply of property
  • Relevant Charitable Purpose (RCP)–the use by a charity for non-business purposes or for use as a village hall or similar
  • Relevant Residential Purpose (RRP)– dwelling used for certain defined residential purposes, eg; children’s home, a hospice or student accommodation
  • Reverse surrender– a tenant surrenders an onerous lease to the landlord and makes a payment to surrender
  • Share of freehold – where the freehold of the property is owned by a company and the shareholders are the owners of the property
  • Single household dwelling– a building designed for occupation by a single household
  • Snagging – the correction of building faults. Usually follows the VAT liability of the original work
  • Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) – tax paid by a purchaser of a property. SDLT is increased if the sale of a commercial property is the subject of an option to tax
  • Substantial reconstruction– certain significant works to a listed building
  • Surrender– a tenant surrenders the lease to the landlord in return for payment
  • Taxable supply– a supply subject to VAT at the standard, reduced or zero-rate
  • Use as a dwelling – a building which was designed or adapted for use as someone’s home and is so used
  • Vendor – entity selling a property
  • Transfer of a Going Concern (TOGC) – the VAT free sale of the assets of a business as a going concern. This may include a tenanted property
  • Zero-rated– a taxable supply subject to VAT at a rate of 0%

We strongly recommend that advice is obtained if any property transaction is being undertaken.

Details of our land and property services may be found here.