Tag Archives: input-tax

VAT: Intention is crucial – The Sonaecom case

By   18 May 2020
0

We cannot control the future…

The Sonaecom case

In the opinion* of the CJEU AG (C-42/19) the importance of a taxpayer’s intention was of utmost importance, regardless of whether that intention was achieved.

Background

Sonaecom intended to acquire a telecoms provider company. As is usual in such cases, input tax was incurred on consultancy received, from, amongst others; accountants and legal service providers. The intention post acquisition was for Sonaecom to make certain charges to the acquired co. These would have been taxable supplies.

Unfortunately, the intended purchase was aborted.

 The issue

The issue before the AG was; as no taxable supplies took place as the deal fell through – to what should the input tax incurred on advice be attributed?

Opinion

In the AG’s view the fact that the acquisition was aborted was no reason for the claim for input tax to denied. This was based on the fact that:

  • Sonaecom was not a “pure holding company”
  • There was a genuine intention to make taxable supplies (to the acquired co)
  • There was a direct and immediate link between the costs and the intended supplies
  • Although the acquisition costs would exceed the proposed management charges, this was not a reason to invalidate the claim
  • The above analysis was not affected by the fact that the transaction did not take place

Commentary

There are often issues in relation to intentions of a taxpayer. It is clear, and was emphasised in this case, that intention is all important. Of course, intentions can change over a period of time and commercial and political events may thwart or cause intentions to be re-evaluated. There is often an issue about evidencing an intention. HMRC usually require comprehensive documentary evidence to demonstrate an objective. Such evidence is sometime not available for various reasons. Consequently, it is prudent for businesses to record (board meeting minutes etc at the very least) the commercial reasons for taking a certain course of action. This issue quite often arises in transactions in land and property – which can create additional technical issues.

There is legislation in place to cover situations when intentions, or actual events change and which affect the original input tax position: The Capital Goods Scheme (CGS) and The Value Added Tax Regulations 1995, Regs 108 and 109.

Other areas of VAT which often to raise issues are management charges and holding companies. HMRC apparently continue to be eager to attack taxpayers in these areas and I have looked at the role of holding companies and the VAT treatment here, here and here.

I think it is useful to bear in mind a question which, in itself does not evidence an intention, but provides commercial coherence – Why were the costs incurred if there was no intention to make the acquisition? This does leave aside the future management charges position but goes some way to provide business logic.

It will be interesting to see how this case proceeds, but I would find it very surprising if the court diverges from this AG opinion.

*  AG’s Opinion

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) consists of one judge from each Member State, assisted by eleven Advocates General whose role is to consider the written and oral submissions to the court in every case that raises a new point of law, and deliver an impartial opinion to the court on the legal solution.

VAT Notice 700/57 Administrative agreements with trade bodies – Update

By   5 May 2020
0

HMRC has published an updated version of VAT Notice 700/57: Administrative agreements with trade bodies.

This is an unusual publication as it lists situations where there are, or can be, deviations from “normal” VAT rules.

The agreements in the Notice permit members of trade bodies to use procedures which take into account their individual circumstances so they may meet their obligations under VAT law. The agreements apply only to areas where HMRC can exercise discretion, and HMRC say that they convey no direct financial advantage or relief from the legal requirements of the tax. However, there can be benefits a business can derive from the arrangements, including, but not limited to; simplification, cashflow, compliance and management.

The agreements can provide unique solutions to particular problems and reduce the burdens on businesses. Some of them might usefully be applied by other businesses, but it should be born in mind that a business cannot adopt any special method based on these agreements unless HMRC has given approval in advance.

The trade bodies covered in the Notice are:

London Bullion Market Association

Brewers’ Society

Association of British Factors and Discounters

Finance Houses Association Ltd

Association of British Insurers

Association of Investment Trust Companies

British Printing Industries Federation

Marine, Aviation and Transport Insurance Underwriters

Association of British Insurers, Lloyd’s of London, the Institute of London Underwriters and British Insurance and Investment Association

National Caravan Council Limited and the British Holiday and Home Park Association Limited

Association of Unit Trust and Investment Managers

British Bankers’ Association

British Vehicle Rental and Leasing Association

Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders

Gaming Board for Great Britain and the British Casino Association

British Phonographic Industry

Thoroughbred Breeders Association and the British Horseracing Board

Meat and Livestock Commission

Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders Limited

Retail Motor Industry Federation

if you or your clients are involved in business covered by, or similar to, the above entities, it maybe worthwhile considering whether any specialised trade agreements may be of benefit.

VAT: Retrospective claims – standard of proof. NHS Lothian case

By   24 April 2020
0

Latest from the courts

An interesting and helpful comment was made by the judge in the NHS Lothian Health Board Court of Session (the Scottish equivalent of the Court of Appeal) case.

Background

The case involved a claim for overpaid VAT going back to 1974. The primary issue was not the existence of the taxpayer’s claim to recover overpaid VAT, but the quantification of that claim, and in particular whether the claim can be quantified with sufficient accuracy to permit an order for repayment of tax to be made. In the previous case it was held that the onus of proving that an amount of tax had been paid and not recovered rested upon the taxpayer and that the standard of proof was the balance of probabilities and Lord Drummond Young agreed with that proposition here.

Judgement

The specific comments which will be of assistance with businesses with similar clams were:

“The fundamental problem in such cases is that primary evidence does not exist owing to the lapse of time. The absence of such evidence, at least in cases such as the present, is not the fault of the taxpayer, and the lack of evidence should not be held against the taxpayer,”

Outcome

The court urged Tax Tribunals (First Tier Tribunal – FTT and Upper Tribunal – UT) to apply a flexible approach to the burden and standard of proof when making decisions in similar cases; of which there is a considerable number. This approach should apply to so called “Fleming” claims and others in respect of overpaid output tax. We understand that 700 such claims were made by NHS authorities in Great Britain alone, and circa 200 of these remain unresolved.

Commentary

In most cases, a taxpayer is only required to retain records for six years. So the comments made in this case should bolster the chances of success for claims made by other businesses, whether they be for overpaid output tax or underclaimed input tax. There are many and varied reasons why sufficiently detailed could be unavailable; we are looking at a potential 46-year time span. In 1974 record keeping was a different world and physical/manual records were usually the only option. It seems only reasonable that HMRC should make the allowances suggested in this case when it is agreed that a claim is valid in all other respects.

Action

If you, or your client, have had a claim rejected on the basis of insufficient supporting primary evidence, it may be worthwhile revisiting it on the basis of this decision. It sets out helpful and clear guidance and provides businesses with effective, appropriate tax relief where applicable.

VAT: Recovery of input tax on fuel costs

By   22 April 2020
0

Fuel costs

Road Fuel Scale Charge (RFSC) simplification.

It is common for a staff member to use a car for both business and private purposes (a staff member also covers sole proprietors and partners). Input tax is only recoverable in respect of the business use, so an apportionment is required. This may be done in the following ways.

  • Apply the RFSC. This is a set figure per month which represents a disallowance for private use and is repaid to HMRC
  • Keep detailed mileage records and only claim for the business element
  • If a business pays a mileage allowance for exact business miles travelled it may reclaim input tax on that actual payment. HMRC publish approved Advisory Fuel Rates, which are used to calculate the payments and the recoverable VAT
  • Do not make a claim at all (if business mileage is minimal or the administration outweighs the cost benefit)

Application

One RFSC must be applied for each car that is used both privately and for business. The fuel scale charges are calculated according to a car’s CO2 emissions and the fixed charge is added to the output figure on the VAT return.

A business will need to check the relevant car’s CO2 emissions figure. This is available for the car’s log book. For dual fuel cars, the lower of the two figures is used.

The calculation

The RFSC allows a business to account for the VAT on fuel in monthly, quarterly or annual returns. When calculating VAT on fuel, if the relevant car has a CO2 emission of 160g, and the business files quarterly returns, the VAT inclusive consideration for a three-month period is £319.00.

The RFSC for the private use of the vehicle will then be calculated as follows: £319.00 x 1/6 (the VAT fraction of the total figure) = £53.16

In this example, the VAT output tax due to HMRC is £53.16 and this is included in Box 1 of the VAT return.

This amount will compensate for any private use of fuel where VAT has already been claimed on the initial purchase of the fuel.

Notes

If a business uses the Flat Rate Scheme no VAT is reclaimable on fuel and no scale charge is applicable.

The RFSC does not apply to commercial vehicles (vans, lorries etc) however, if there is a significant level of private mileage, VAT claims should be adjusted to exclude input tax on this.

HMRC publish updated RFSC valuation tables annually. The latest table is here

Input tax claims may be restricted due to partial exemption or non-business activities.

Help

HMRC have also published a useful ready reckoner tool which assists with the process here

Mileage payments

If a business recovers input VAT based on mileage payments made to employees, it must ensure that employees submit fuel VAT receipts evidencing that they have incurred costs and VAT on fuel. Without such receipts, HMRC may deny the VAT recovery on mileage reimbursements. Clearly, the total VAT incurred on fuel must exceed the business element claimed.

Penalties

Unfortunately, as always with VAT, if errors are made, penalties and interest could apply.

VAT: Bad Debt Relief – Increase due to coronavirus. A guide

By   17 April 2020
0

The current coronavirus pandemic has thrown up unprecedented difficulties for society as a whole and significant difficulties for commerce. We have considered UK Government’s VAT assistance in previous articles, here here here and here and this is clearly welcomed.

What has become clear is that businesses and consumers will fall into default in increasing numbers as the economy worsens and it is anticipated that the ability to settle of debts on time will significantly decrease and it is apparent that many debts will never be settled. Consequently, it appears timely to look at the available relief.

The VAT position

VAT registered businesses usually account for tax on an accruals basis (but see CAS) and will therefore be required to account for output tax in the same VAT period as an invoice is issued to a customer. If that invoice is not paid and a bad debt arises this would mean that tax has been accounted for on a payment which has not been received.

Relief

Anything which can relieve the burden of VAT is to be welcomed, especially in such trying times. So VAT Bad Debt Relief (BDR) is a useful tool if a business is aware of it and understand when it may be claimed.

It is at the very least frustrating when a client does not pay, and in some cases this situation can lead to the end of a business. At least the VAT charged to the client should not become a cost to a supplier. The BDR mechanism goes some way to protect a business from payment defaulters.

There is a relief however, as normal with tax, there are specific conditions:

Conditions for claiming BDR

The supplier must have supplied goods or services for a consideration in money and must have accounted for and paid VAT on the supply. All or part of the consideration must have been written off as a bad debt by making the appropriate entry in the business’ records (this does not have to be a “formal” procedure and need not be notified to the customer). At least six months (but not more than four years and six months) must have elapsed since the later of the date of supply or the due date for payment.

Records required

Various records and evidence must be kept (for four years from the date of claim), in particular to identify:

  • the time and nature of the supply, the purchaser, and the consideration
  • the amount of VAT chargeable on the supply
  • the accounting period when this VAT was accounted for and paid to HMRC
  • any payment received for the supply
  • entries in the refund for bad debts account
  • the accounting period in which the claim is made

Procedure for claiming BDR

This part is straightforward: The claim is made by including the amount of the refund in Box 4 of the VAT Return for the period in which the debt becomes over six months old. The amount of BDR is either set-off against output tax due, or may create a refund position with HMRC.

Repayment of refund

Repayment of VAT refunded is required where payment is subsequently received or where the above conditions have not been complied with.

Adjustment of input tax for the debtor

Businesses are required to monitor the time they take to pay their suppliers and repay input tax claimed if they have not paid the supplier within six months. Subsequent payment of all or part of the debt will allow a corresponding reclaim of input tax. This is an easy assessment for HMRC to make at inspections, so businesses should make reviewing this matter this a regular exercise.

Finally, there is tax point planning available to defer a tax point until payment is received for providers of continuous supplies of services. Please see here

More on general VAT payment problems here.

VAT: Coronavirus latest – correction of errors

By   9 April 2020
0

Correcting errors on your VAT Return

HMRC have announced that, due to coronavirus, it will no longer be accepting paper copies of VAT652s by post.

If an error is discovered on a past VAT return it is  necessary to report it to HMRC on form VAT652 if it is £10,000 (net of all errors) or more of VAT. More details here

email

A business must now email its VAT652 form to:

Telephone

A business can call to check HMRC has received its error correction notification if it has not had an acknowledgement after 21 days.

Errors cannot be corrected over the phone.

Telephone: 0300 200 3700

This is said to be a temporary measure, but I cannot see why HMRC would revert to a paper based system when the virus poses less of a threat.

Remember: stay in!

VAT: Crowdfunding – What is taxable?

By   9 April 2020
0

What is crowdfunding?

Crowdfunding is the practice of funding a project or venture by raising many small amounts of money from a large number of people, typically via the internet on specifically designed platforms and is an alternative to traditional ways of raising finance. The model is usually based on three parties: the project initiator who proposes the idea or project to be funded, individuals or groups who support the idea, and a moderating organisation (the “platform”) that brings the parties together to launch the idea.

VAT Treatment

The VAT treatment of supplies that might potentially be made is no different to similar financing arrangements, for example; sponsorship, donations and investments made through more traditional routes. Whether a recipient of crowdfunding is liable to charge and pay VAT depends on the facts in each case.

Examples

Donations

  • where nothing is given in return for the funding, it will be treated as a donation and not liable to VAT – the position is the same where all that the funder receives is a bare acknowledgement, such as a mention in a programme or something similar

Goods and/or services

  • where the funder receives goods or services that have a real value associated with them, for example; clothing, tickets, DVDs, film viewings, output tax will be due

Combination

  • where the payment is for a combination of the two examples above, if it is clear that the donation element is optional then that part of the sponsorship can be treated as a non-taxable donation and the supply will be taxable. If a donation element cannot be carved out, it is likely that all of the payment will be considered as VATable

Investment

  • where the funding takes the form of an investment where the funder is entitled to a financial return such as; interest, dividends or profit share, any payment due to the funder is unlikely to be liable to output tax, The reason why most of these arrangements are outside the scope of VAT is that the provision of capital in a business venture is not seen as a supply for VAT purposes

Royalties

  • if the arrangement is that the funder receives royalties based on a supply of intellectual property or some other similar benefit the payment is likely to be consideration for a taxable supply and output tax will be due

VAT registration 

If income from the sources above which are deemed to be subject to VAT exceeds the VAT registration limit (currently £85,000 in any twelve-month period) the person, in whichever legal identity, such as; individual, company, partnership, Trust etc will be liable to register for VAT. If income is below this limit, it will be possible, but not mandatory to VAT register. The benefits of voluntary registration here.

Input tax recovery

If VAT registered, any input tax incurred on costs relating to crowdfunding is usually recoverable (see here for exceptions). However, if the costs relate to donations or some types of investment then input tax claims are specifically blocked as they would relate to non-business activities.

Commentary

There can be difficulties in establishing the tax liability of crowdfunding and in a broader sense “sponsorship” in general. However, experience insists that the biggest issue is initially identifying that there may be a VAT issue at all. If you, or your clients are involved in crowdfunding, or have sponsors, it would be prudent to review the VAT treatment of the activities.

VAT and Duty on exports and imports post Brexit – a guide

By   7 April 2020
0

Exports and Imports – post Brexit

VAT and Duty on exports and imports

With Brexit soon to become a reality, it is important that UK business understand the importance of exporting and importing goods. As matters stand, the UK will become a “third country” and as such will need to go through all the processes that apply to non-EU countries when goods cross borders to sales and purchases to/from existing EU countries. This mainly means customs duties applying to goods that have, to date, been duty free as the EU is a single market.

Whether importing or exporting, there are important VAT and duty rules and procedures. A business must ensure that it charges and pays the right amount of VAT and duty. The first step for moving goods into, or out of, the UK will be to obtain an EORI number. Details here.

Responsibilities for importers

  • the importer is normally responsible for clearing the goods through UK customs and paying any taxes
  • the supplier needs to provide the documentation an importer needs to clear the goods through customs (and to make payment to the supplier)
  • now, if you are importing (even from EU countries) you are likely to have to pay import duty. This cannot be reclaimed from HMRC
  • a business’ responsibilities depend on what it has agreed in the contract. To minimise the risk of disputes, your contract should use one of the internationally recognised Incoterms. These are explained here
  • check what import duty applies – import duty is based on the type of goods you are importing, the country they originate from and their value
  • HMRC’s Integrated Tariff sets out the classification of goods and the rates of duty in detail. Your Trade Association or your import agent may be able to assist with classification. You can find reputable freight forwarders through the British International Freight Association here 
  • an importer may need proof of the origin of the goods to claim reduced import duty for goods from certain countries
  • a valuation document is also normally required for imports above a set value
  • complete an import declaration. This is normally done using the Single Administrative Document (SAD)
  • pay VAT and duty to get the goods released
  • the VAT applicable is the normal UK rate for the imported goods when sold in the UK
  • regular importers can defer payment of VAT and duty by opening a deferment account with HMRC. A security payment will need to be provided and payments must be via Direct Debit
  • From 1 January 2021 Postponed Accounting for import VAT to be introduced for all goods including those from the EU
  • account for VAT on returns
  • HMRC will send a C79 certificate showing the import VAT you have paid
  • VAT on imports (supported by C79 evidence) may be claimed in the same way as reclaims of input tax incurred on purchases in the UK
  • import duty cannot be reclaimed

Responsibilities for exporters

    • the exporter is normally responsible for clearing goods outwards through UK customs
    • the customer is normally responsible for overseas customs clearance and taxes (depending on the Incoterms). Further details on how other countries handle import duties and taxes are available from the Department for International Trade
    • the exporter will need to provide its customer with the documentation they need to clear goods into their country (and to pay you)
    • the exporter’s responsibilities depend on what it has agreed in the contract (see Incoterms above)
    • the exporter will need to provide its customer with the documents they need to import the goods into their country. These documents can also be part of the process of getting paid
    • as a minimum, the seller will need documents recording details of the:
    • exporter
    • customer
    • goods and their value
    • export destination
    • how the goods will be transported
    • route they will take
  • keep copies of all documents giving details of all the sales which have been made.
  • record the value of your exports on your VAT return
  • consider any responsibility you have for overseas customs clearance and taxes. Normally, as an exporter, you will have agreed that your customer handles this. However, take specialist advice, or use an expert agent, if you are responsible – this will depend on Incoterms

Tips

  • freight forwarders can handle customs clearance as well as transport
  • exporting can be simpler if you choose to sell to a single agent or distributor in an overseas country. However, this may not suit your export strategy
  • exports are usually zero-rated. However, exporters must keep proof that the goods have been physically exported along with normal commercial documentation
  • the exporter must declare the export. This is usually done by completing a Single Administrative Document (SAD), also known as form C88

Excise duty

  • check whether any goods being purchased are subject to excise duty
  • excise duty is payable on; fuel, alcohol and tobacco products
  • if goods are subject to excise duty, it is paid at the same time as payments for VAT and import duty are made
  • VAT is charged on the value of the goods plus excise duty

Customs warehouses

If you expect to store imports for a long time it will be worth considering using a Customs warehouse.

  • goods stored in a customs warehouse, will not be subject to import duty and VAT until they are removed from the warehouse
  • storage ‘in bond’ is often used for products subject to excise duty, such as wine and cigarettes, although it is not limited to these goods

Relief for re-exported goods

  • it may be possible to take advantage of Inward Processing Relief (IPR) rules so that no import duty and VAT is payable
  • IPR can apply to imports that you process before re-exporting them

If you import or export regularly, find out about alternative procedures

  • For example, businesses that import regularly and in large volumes can use processes such as Customs Freight Simplified Procedures.

Summary

If you are new to acquisitions, importing or exporting, it may be worthwhile talking to an expert. This article only scratches the surface of the subject. There can be significant savings made by accurately classifying goods, and applying the correct procedures and rates will avoid assessments and penalties being levied. Planning may also be available to defer when tax is paid on imports and acquisitions.

Budget 2020 – VAT implications

By   11 March 2020
0

A summary of how the 2020 budget changes VAT rules:

e-publications

Zero rating will apply to e-publications from 1 December 2020. This brings e-publications in line with traditional printed matter. The zero rate will apply to:

  • e-books
  • e-newspapers
  • e-magazines
  • academic e-journals

Presumably, this brings an end to HMRC’s arguments set out in the News Corp case.

Postponed Accounting

From 1 January 2021 postponed accounting will apply to all imports of goods, including those from the EU. This will provide an important boost to those VAT registered UK businesses which are integrated in international supply chains as they adapt to the UK’s position post Brexit.

Sanitary products

From 1 January 2021 the zero rate will apply to women’s sanitary products. This is calculated to save the average women £40 over her life.

Consultation

A consultation paper will be published to gather views on the potential approach to duty and tax-free goods policy post Brexit.

Cross-border goods policy

An informal consultation process will be launched in spring 2020 on the VAT and Excise treatment of goods crossing UK borders after Brexit.

Fund management

As announced on 4 March 2020 the government is legislating to clarify when fund management services are exempt from VAT.

Financial services

An industry working group will be set up to review how financial services are treated for VAT purposes. Presumably how Brexit will affect such services.

“Quick Fixes” Directive

Legislation will be introduced to simplify rules for the VAT treatment of intra-EU movements of call-off stock, allowing businesses to delay accounting for VAT until the goods are called-off.

Partial Exemption

Following the recent call for evidence on the simplification of the VAT rules on Partial Exemption and the Capital Goods Scheme, the government has said it will continue to engage with businesses in relation to their responses and will publish a response in due course.

Commentary

These proposed measures will be broadly be welcomed by business. Especially those in relation to e-publications and Postponed Accounting. It was widely expected that HMRC would lose its argument that e-publications and hard copy publications should be treated differently in any case. Postponed Accounting takes us back to the pre-1990s era. It looks very much like this means a “No-Deal” and although Postponed Accounting may be an easement for some aspects, it remains unnecessary if an agreement with the EU can be reached. However, there appears to be no political will nor appetite to reach such an agreement, so business suffers.