Tag Archives: intra-EU

VAT: New gov.uk EORI tool

By Marcus Ward 21 January 2021

Gov.uk has provided a new tool to check a business’ EORI number. (This used to be an EC resource now not available due to Brexit).

A guide to EORI here

A business may need to demonstrate to HMRC that it has carried out proper due diligence in certain cases.

Contact

If you have queries, or would like to obtain specific EORI advice, contact the HMRC EORI team using the online form

Access

Who has access to an EORI number?

The general public can access limited data, When a business is notified of its EORI number, it will be asked whether it objects to this data being published on the site.

VAT – Bringing goods into the UK from other EU countries

By Marcus Ward 8 June 2018

VAT Reverse Charge for Goods – Acquisition Tax and Intrastat

If a business registered for VAT in the UK receives goods from other Member States in the EU (technically known as acquisitions rather than imports) it will not pay overseas VAT in the Member State from which they are purchased. However, a “Reverse Charge” applies to such purchases The rate of VAT payable is the same rate that you would have paid had the goods been supplied to the purchasing business by a UK supplier. This VAT is known as acquisition tax and a business can normally reclaim this VAT if the acquisitions relate to taxable supplies it makes. This is usually resale of the goods, but in some circumstances the goods will be “consumed” by a business. In these cases, if the business is partly exempt, there may be a restriction of the amount of acquisition tax claimable.

VAT free

In order to obtain intra-EU goods VAT free a business must give its supplier its UK VAT number. The supplier is obliged to make checks to determine whether the number is valid and if it is it allows the supplier to treat the supply as VAT free. VAT number validity may be checked here

Why?

This system ensures that tax is paid (and paid in the “correct” Member State) and also avoids “rate shopping” where a business which cannot recover input tax could, without these rules, buy goods VAT free to the detriment of suppliers in its own country. With acquisition tax, it is a level playing field for all EU businesses.

Record-keeping for acquisition tax

A business must enter the VAT details on its VAT return. The time of supply for VAT purposes is the time of acquisition – normally, the earlier of:

the 15th day of the month following the one in which the goods come into the UK
the date the supplier issued their invoice

A business must account for the acquisition tax on the return for the period in which the time of supply occurs, and may treat this as input tax on the same return. This, for most businesses is a bookkeeping exercise and is far preferable than the previous system when goods had to be physically entered at borders. This issue forms part of the problems for Brexit, especially with the UK’s only land border between Northern Ireland and the ROI.

Value of acquired goods for VAT purposes

The value for VAT of any goods brought into the UK is the same as the value for VAT of the goods had they been supplied to the purchaser by a UK supplier. A business must account for the value of the goods or services in £sterling, so it must convert their value into £sterling if the goods were priced in another currency.

Intrastat

Intrastat is the name given to the system for collecting statistics on the trade in goods between EU Member States. The requirements of Intrastat are similar in all EU Member States.

It is worth noting that:

the supply of services is excluded from Intrastat
only movements which represent physical trade in goods are covered by Intrastat, although there are some movements that are excluded

Intrastat – use of information

The information collected by the Intrastat system is a key component for Balance of Payments (BOP) and National Accounts (NA) data, which is regarded as an important economic indicator of the UK’s performance.

The Office for National Statistics uses the monthly trade in goods figures collected by HMRC together with the trade in services survey to produce the BOP and NA figures.

The Bank of England uses monthly trade data as part of its key indicators for gauging the state of the UK and world economic environment to set interest rates each month.

Government departments use the statistics to help set overall trade policy and generate initiatives on new trade areas.

Beyond the UK, trade statistics data are used by the EU to set trade policy and inform decisions made by such institutions as the European Central Bank, the United Nations and the International Monetary Fund.

The commercial world uses statistics to assess markets both within the UK (for example, to assess import opportunities) and externally (for example, to establish new markets for its goods).

Intrastat – the practicalities

All VAT registered businesses acquiring goods must complete two boxes (8 and 9) on its VAT return showing the total value of any goods acquired from VAT registered suppliers in other EU Member States (known as arrivals). In addition, larger VAT registered businesses must supply further information each month on their trade in goods with other EU Member States. This is known as an Intranet Supplementary Declaration (SD) …which is a subject for another day. For arrivals, the current threshold is £1.5 million and this limit is reviewed annually.

How this system will work (if at all) after Brexit remains to be seen, but given past experiences I am not optimistic.

VAT Latest from the courts – Reverse Charge

By Marcus Ward 13 February 2017

The First Tier Tribunal case of University Of Newcastle Upon Tyne is a useful reminder of the impact of the Reverse Charge.

A brief guide to the Reverse Charge is included below.

Background

As with many UK universities, Newcastle was keen to encourage applications to study from new students from overseas. This is an important form of income for the institution. It used local (overseas) agents to recruit students. Some 40% of those students were studying as undergraduates, 40% as postgraduates on one year “taught” courses and 20% as postgraduate research students studying for doctorates. In 2014 the University had agreements with more than 100 agents worldwide. The agents used their own resources to recruit students for universities around the world, including in the UK. The University entered into contractual arrangements with agents and paid commission to them. In 2008 the University paid agent commissions of £1.034m, rising to £2.214m in 2012.

The Tribunal was required to consider whether the services supplied by the agents were a single supply to University or separate supplies to both the University and students. If the entire supply is to the University then the Reverse Charge is applicable and, because the University is partly exempt, this would create a VAT cost to it. If the supplies are to both the students and the University, the Reverse Charge element would be less and the VAT cost reduced. (There were changes to the Place Of Supply legislation during the period under consideration, but I have tried to focus on the overall impact in this article.)

The University contended that agents made two supplies: a supply to the University of recruitment services and a supply to students of support services. The commission paid by the University should therefore be apportioned so as to reflect in part direct consideration paid by the University for supplies of services to it, and in part third party consideration for services supplied to the students. The supplies to students would not made in the UK and therefore were not subject to UK VAT.

Decision

After thorough consideration of all of the relevant material, the judge decided that the agents made a single supply of services to the University and make no supplies to students. This meant that the University must account for VAT on the full value of services received since 2010 under the Reverse Charge (although before 2010 different rules on place of supply applied). Additionally, it was decided the University was not entitled to recover as input tax VAT for which it is required to account by means of a Reverse Charge. There was no direct and immediate link between the commission paid to agents and any taxable output of the University or the economic activities of the University as a whole.

Commentary

It is understood that the way the University recruited students using overseas agents is common amongst most Universities in the UK, so this ruling will have a direct impact on them. It was hardly a surprising decision, but underlines the need for all businesses to consider the impact of the application of the Reverse Charge. Of course, the Reverse Charge will only create an actual VAT cost if a business is partly exempt, or involved in non-business activities. The value of the Reverse Charge also counts towards the VAT registration threshold. This means that if a fully exempt business receives Reverse Charge services from abroad, it may be required to VAT register (depending on value). Generally, this means an increased VAT cost. This situation may also affect a charity or a NFP entity.

The case also highlights the importance of contracts, documentation and website wording (should any more reminders be needed). VAT should always be borne in mind when entering into similar arrangements. It may also be possible to structure arrangements to avoid or mitigate VAT costs if carried out at an appropriate time.

We can assist with any of the above and are happy to discuss this with you.

Guide – Reverse charge on services received from overseas

Normally, the supplier of a service is the person who must account to the tax authorities for any VAT due on the supply. However, in certain situations, the position is reversed and it is the customer who must account for any VAT due. This is known as the ‘Reverse Charge’ procedure. Generally, the Reverse Charge must be applied to services which are received by a business in the UK VAT free from overseas.

Accounting for VAT and recovery of input tax.

Where the Reverse Charge procedure applies, the recipient of the services must act as both the supplier and the recipient of the services. On the same VAT return, the recipient must

account for output tax, calculated on the full value of the supply received, in Box 1;
(subject to partial exemption and non-business rules) include the VAT stated in box 1 as input tax in Box 4; and;
include the full value of the supply in both Boxes 6 and 7.

Value of supply.

The value of the deemed supply is to be taken to be the consideration in money for which the services were in fact supplied or, where the consideration did not consist or not wholly consist of money, such amount in money as is equivalent to that consideration. The consideration payable to the overseas supplier for the services excludes UK VAT but includes any taxes levied abroad.

Time of supply.

The time of supply of such services is the date the supplies are paid for or, if the consideration is not in money, the last day of the VAT period in which the services are performed.

The outcome

The effect of the provisions is that the Reverse Charge has no net cost to the recipient if he can attribute the input tax to taxable supplies and can therefore reclaim it in full. If he cannot, the effect is to put him in the same position as if had received the supply from a UK supplier rather than from one outside the UK. Thus the charge aims to avoid cross border VAT rate shopping. It is not possible to attribute the input tax created directly to the deemed (taxable) supply.