Orange squash, petrol, ice cream, and poodle food are rated as “luxuries”, while caviar, top shelf magazines, and labrador food are not.
Tag Archives: marcus-ward-tax
VAT: DIY housebuilders can make more than one claim – The Ellis case
Latest from the courts
In the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) case of Andrew Ellis and Jane Bromley [2021] TC08277, the issue was whether a person constructing their own house can make more than one claim for VAT incurred.
Background
The DIY Housebuilder’s Scheme enables a DIY housebuilder to recover VAT incurred on the construction of a house in which the constructor will live. Details here.
In this case, the specific issue was whether, despite the HMRC guidance notes on the scheme claim form explicitly stating that only one claim can be made, whether two claims may be submitted and paid by the respondent.
The appellant constructed a house over a period of five years (he was a jobbing builder and the work was generally only undertaken at weekends and holidays). To aid cash flow, an initial claim was made, followed by a second two years later.
The relevant legislation is The VAT Act 1994 section 35.
Decision
The appeal was allowed. The FTT found that HMRC’s rule that only one claim could be made under the DIY housebuilder’s scheme was ultra vires and that multiple claims should be permitted.
The judge stated that “…there is no express indication that only one claim may be made. Like many provisions, section 35 VATA is drafted in the singular. Drafting in the singular is an established technique to assist in clarity and to enable the proposal to be dealt with succinctly. As there is no express indication to the contrary in section 35 VATA, section 6 Interpretation Act 1978 applies to confirm that the reference to “a claim” in section 35 VATA must be read as including “claims”.
Commentary
This is good news for claimants who often must wait a number of years for a house to be built and therefore carry the VAT cost until the end of the project.
This case presumably means that it is possible to make claims as the project progresses and there is no need to wait until completion.
We await comment on this case from HMRC, but it is hoped that clarification will be forthcoming on whether the result of this case will be accepted.
VAT: HMRC OSS updates
HMRC has issued two new documents which provide practical guidance for users of the One Stop Shop (OSS).
They cover how to pay the VAT due on an OSS return and how to use the service to submit an OSS VAT return if a business is registered for the OSS Union Scheme. A link has been added to allow a business to submit a OSS return directly.
VAT: Fraudster ordered to pay £37 million
Latest from the courts
A high level fraudster who skipped his trial and fled to Dubai has been ordered to pay more than £37 million. Failure to do so will result in ten years in prison. He played a major role in this missing trader fraud (MTIC) which involves the theft of Value Added Tax from HMRC. He was part of a conspiracy to use a network of companies and a huge number of transactions to cover up the theft of VAT.
Adam Umerji, 43, was convicted in his absence of offences of conspiracy to cheat the government’s revenue and conspiracy to transfer criminal property, in a prosecution conducted by the CPS Specialist Fraud Division after a complex criminal investigation by HMRC.
Background
Missing trader fraud (also called missing trader intra-community fraud or MTIC fraud) involves the theft of VAT from a government by fraudsters who exploit VAT rules, most commonly the EU rules which provide that the movement of goods between Member States is VAT free. There are different variations of the fraud but they generally involve a trader charging VAT on the sale of goods and absconding with the VAT (instead of paying the VAT to the government’s taxation authority). The term “missing trader” is used because the fraudster has gone missing with the VAT.
A common form of missing trader fraud is carousel fraud. In carousel fraud, VAT and goods are passed around between companies and jurisdictions.