Tag Archives: output-tax

VAT treatment of lost, stolen, damaged or destroyed goods

By Marcus Ward 24 March 2025

Is output tax due on goods that, for various reasons, cannot be sold, or are sold at a discount?

HMRC says that the VAT treatment depends on whether or not there was actually a supply of goods, what happened to them, who was responsible for them at the time and whether a VAT invoice was issued. The value of any supply will also need to recognise any credit given to the customer.

So, as often is the case with the tax, the answer is: “It depends”. So, let’s look at the categories to find out:

Lost goods

This depends on who lost the goods.

Sometimes a business will sell goods to a customer, but they did not receive them because they went astray. This could happen, for example, if goods are lost in the post.

customer is responsible for loss

If the customer is responsible for any losses before the goods are delivered, then VAT is due on the full amount of the sale.

supplier responsible for loss

If the supplier is responsible for any losses before the goods are delivered, then the way VAT is dealt with will depend on whether an invoice has been issued.

If an invoice has been issued, output tax is due on the amount invoiced, less the value of any credit given to the customer. So, if credit has been given a full refund, no VAT will be due.

If no invoice has been issued, there is no VAT due. This is because nothing has been supplied. It is prudent to make a note in the business records that the goods were lost an no invoice was raised.

Stolen goods

If goods are stolen from a business’ premises no VAT is due – as long as any customer has not been invoiced. HMRC are very likely to examine such circumstances as it is sometimes used as an ‘excuse’ for underdeclarations. Consequently, we always advise businesses to hold as much evidence as possible to support a claim that theft has taken place.

Goods stolen from a supplier’s premises after they have been sold to a customer- If the contract with the customer means that they are responsible for the goods while they are on the supplier’s premises – there has been a supply and output tax is due.

If the customer is not responsible for the goods when they are stolen, then if:

a VAT invoice issued – VAT is due on the amount invoiced (but subject to subsequent amendment to the quantum)
no invoice has been issued – there is no VAT due because there is no supply

NB: If cash is stolen from a business, this does not reduce the value of output tax on any supply.

Fraud

If goods are lost due to fraud it can be difficult to demonstrate or evidence. To avoid paying output tax on goods lost to a fraud a business is required to:

report the incident to the police
contact HMRC and give them the case details – this will entail providing a crime or case reference number given by the police. HMRC will consider each case and advise appropriately

Damaged goods

Damaged goods may be sold on at a discounted price, or they might have some scrap value. Output tax is due on whatever income is received for the goods sold. If an insurer makes a payment in respect of the damage, no VAT is due on this income.

Destroyed goods

If goods are destroyed such that they cannot be sold, and these are handed over (or what is left of them) to the insurer, no VAT is due on the disposal. Furthermore, there is no output tax due on any money received from the insurer. HMRC will need to see evidence of the insurance claim, and details of any insurance payment, on their next inspection of the business.

Records

Maintaining meticulous records is crucial for VAT compliance and it is very likely that such issues will be examined closely on HMRC inspections. This is because unexpected reductions in output tax will usually trigger enquiries. Input tax claims for the original purchase of the goods will be unaffected, so any mark-up type exercise will flag up the discrepancy.

VAT: Are hair transplants ‘medical care’? – The Advanced Hair Technology Ltd case

By Marcus Ward 12 March 2025

Latest from the courts

In the Advanced Hair Technology Ltd First-Tier Tribunal (FTT) case the issue was whether hair transplants are exempt supplies of medical care, or were they for ‘cosmetic’ purposes and consequently standard rated?

Background

Advanced Hair Technology Ltd (AHT) was a medical practice trading as The Farjo Hair Institute which specialised in hair restoration surgery. It treated conditions related to hair loss, in particular androgenetic alopecia (AGA). Dr Farjo who carried out the work is qualified is a medical practitioner with the Royal College of Surgeons. The output tax which HMRC deemed due was circa £2,500,000.

The sole issue was what AHT provided covered by the definition ‘medical care’?

Legislation

The VAT Act 1994, Schedule 9, Group 7, item 1 covers services which are for the primary purpose of protecting, restoring, or maintaining health: “medical care”.

Contentions

AHT argued that it was treating patients for medical conditions, as opposed to providing aesthetic surgery and consequently, its supplies were exempt. The appellant explained that several patients believed that hair loss had affected their self-confidence and so the surgery improved their overall health (which includes a mental health element). Furthermore, the surgery helps to protect the skin from future photodamage, minor trauma and thermal insult.

HMRC contended that none of the patients had any recorded prior psychiatric conditions, eg; depression or anxiety, nor had any stated that they were looking to benefit from the surgery beyond it improving their appearance and confidence. Additionally, no recipients of the treatment said that they were seeking any of the above physical protections.

Therefore, the treatment was a standard rated cosmetic procedure.

Decision

The meaning of ‘medical care’ was considered by the Court of Appeal in its decision in Mercy Global [2023] EWCA Civ 1073.

The court agreed with HMRC that a “principal purpose” test must be applied in all cases.

The evidence before the FTT was that by the age of 70 at least 80% of caucasian men suffer from hair loss as a result of AGA, and this is part of the normal process of aging. AGA is not considered a medical condition but rather a symptom.

AHT’s contention that the procedures serve a therapeutic purpose related to psychological issues was dismissed due to a lack of evidence from qualified practitioners. This reinforced the FTT’s view that the treatments were primarily cosmetic, rather than for medical reasons because altering one’s physical appearance was for aesthetic purposes.

The relevant supplies were therefore outside the exemption.

The appeal was dismissed.

Commentary

The judgment provides some guidance on the interpretation of the definition of medical care for the purposes of the exemption and follows similar recent cases which we covered here:

Skin Science

Skin Rich

The concept of the “provision of medical care” does not include medical interventions carried out for a purpose other than that of diagnosing, treating and in so far as possible, curing diseases or health disorders and it is the purpose of the medical intervention rather than merely the qualifications of the person providing it that is key in determining the VAT liability.

There has been an ongoing debate as to what constitutes medical care. Over 20 years ago I was advising a large London clinic on this very point and much turned on whether patients’ mental health was improved by undergoing what many would regard as cosmetic procedures. We were somewhat handicapped in our arguments by the fact that many of the patients were lap dancers undergoing breast augmentation on the direction of the owner of a certain club…

It is worth remembering that not all services provided by a medically registered practitioner are exempt. The question of whether the medical care exemption is engaged in any given case will turn on the particular facts .

Interestingly, the judge here stated that the medical exemption may apply to some patients whose hair loss was a result of trauma caused by cancer treatment.

VAT Returns: A box-by-box guide

By Marcus Ward 10 March 2025

VAT Basics

Return boxes explained – what goes where? A general overview.

Box 1 VAT due in the period on sales and other outputs

The amount of VAT due on all goods and services supplied in the period covered by the return. This is output tax. The value of output tax may be affected by VAT:

on credit notes issued
when refunds are made
on goods taken in part-exchange
underdeclared or overdeclared on previous returns within certain de minimis

VAT may also be due on supplies outside the mainstream of a business, eg:

fuel used for private motoring where VAT is accounted for using a scale charge
the sale of stocks and assets
goods taken out of the business for private use
VAT due under a reverse charge
supplies to staff
gifts of goods that cost more than £50
certain distance sales to Northern
commission received for selling something on behalf of a third-party
VAT shown on self-billed invoices issued by your customer
VAT due on imports accounted for through postponed VAT accounting

Box 2 VAT due in the period on acquisitions of goods made in Northern Ireland from the EU

Since 1 January 2021, a business is only allowed to make acquisitions on goods brought into Northern Ireland from the EU. For acquisitions, the VAT due on all goods and related costs bought from VAT-registered suppliers in the EU should be included.

Box 3 total VAT due

Show the total VAT due, the total of boxes 1 and 2. This is the total output VAT for the period.

Box 4 VAT reclaimed in the period on purchases and other inputs

Show the total amount of deductible VAT charged on business purchases. This is input tax for the period.

This will include:

VAT paid on imports
imports accounted for through postponed VAT accounting.
claims for bad debt relief (BDR)
payments on removals from a warehousing regime or a free zone
VAT shown on self-billed invoices issued by you
acquisitions of goods into Northern Ireland from the EU

Certain VAT paid by a business should not be included in box 4, some examples here.

Adjustments to the amount claimed may be required for

VAT on any credit notes received
certain VAT underdeclared or overdeclared on earlier returns
partial exemption

Box 5 net VAT to pay or reclaim

Deduct the smaller from the larger of values in boxes 3 and 4 and enter the difference in box 5.

If the figure in box 3 is more than the figure in box 4, the difference is the amount payable to HMRC. If the figure in box 3 is less than the figure in box 4, HMRC will repay this.

Box 6 total value of sales and all other outputs excluding any VAT

Show the total VAT exclusive value of all business sales and other specific outputs. These will include:

zero-rated, reduced rate and exempt supplies
fuel scale charges
exports
distance sales to Northern Ireland which are above the distance selling threshold or, if below the threshold the overseas supplier opts to register for VAT in the UK
reverse charge transactions
supplies which are outside the scope of UK VAT (this is debateable, but HMRC require this information)
deposits that an invoice has been issued for
net value of the road fuel scale charge

Box 7 total value of purchases and all other inputs excluding any VAT

Show the total net value of expenditure. This will include:

imports
acquisitions of goods brought into Northern Ireland from the EU
reverse charge transactions
capital assets

Boxes 8 and 9 only need to be completed goods cross the Northern Ireland border.

Box 8 value of supplies of goods to the EU

For supplies of goods and related costs, excluding any VAT, from Northern Ireland the EU made from 1 January 2021.

Box 9 value of acquisitions of goods from the EU

For acquisitions of goods and related costs, excluding any VAT, from the EU into Northern Ireland from 1 January 2021.

NB: If a business uses one of the following schemes there may be different rules for completing some of the boxes on returns.

flat rate scheme
cash accounting
annual accounting
margin schemes for second hand goods, works of art, antiques and collectors’ items
payments on account.

VAT Domestic Reverse Charge procedure Notice updated

By Marcus Ward 4 March 2025

HMRC has updated – VAT Notice 735: Domestic reverse charge procedure

The Notice sets out how the Domestic Reverse Charge (DRC) makes supplies of standard or reduced rated construction services between construction or building businesses subject to the charge. This means that the recipient of the supply will be liable to account for VAT due, instead of the supplier. Consequently, the customer in the construction industry receiving the supply of construction services will be required to pay the VAT directly to HMRC rather than paying it to the supplier. It will be able to reclaim this VAT subject to the normal VAT rules. The DRC will apply throughout the supply chain up to the point where the customer receiving the supply is no longer a business that makes supplies of construction services (a so-called end user).

The supplies to which the DRC applies are set out here

The update includes information on recipients of DRC supplies that are not VAT registered. Broadly; if a business buys specified goods or services, it may make it liable to VAT registered on the strength of the value of the DRC.

A VAT Did you know?

By Marcus Ward 26 February 2025

Under one VAT scheme, zero-rated and exempt supplies are subject to VAT – as are those which are “Outside the scope of UK VAT”.

Which, or course, makes entire sense.

VAT: Time to pay guidance updated

By Marcus Ward 18 February 2025

HMRC’s guidance: How to pay a debt to HMRC with a Time to Pay arrangement was updated on 17 February 2025. This covers businesses which owe a debt to the department.

The updates cover:

Information about when a payment plan can be set up without contacting HMRC has been added.
Section ‘How we work out debt repayments’ has been removed as the information is covered in the section
Information to work out what businesses can afford to pay has been updated in the section ‘How we work out what you can afford to pay’.

If a business owes VAT

It can set up a payment plan to spread the cost of its latest VAT bill online without calling HMRC if it:

has missed the deadline to pay a VAT bill
owes £100,000 or less
plan to pay its debt off within the next 12 months
has a debt for an accounting period that started in 2023 or later
does not have any other payment plans or debts with HMRC
has filed all your tax returns

More information here: set up a payment plan online.

How to contact HMRC to discuss a Time to Pay arrangement

If a business cannot pay its tax bill and needs assistance (ie; the online arrangements above are not applicable) we recommend that it should contact HMRC as soon as possible.

VAT: When is a bar a bar? – The Anglia Ruskin Students’ Union case

By Marcus Ward 17 February 2025

Latest from the courts

A student union tried to argue that a bar is not a bar. It did not go well.

In the case of The Anglia Ruskin Students’ Union the High Court considered the appellant’s application for judicial review of HMRC’s decision that “92” which was operated on the university’s campus was a bar.

The importance of this description of the venue was that if it was indeed a bar, the supplies from it would be standard rated. This is because the supplies of catering to students by eligible bodies, including universities”, are exempt from VAT, on the basis that the supplies are closely related to exempt supplies of education, however, the exemption does not cover food and drink sold in bars.

The union contended that ‘bar’ means a place that does not supply catering, or, alternatively, predominantly or mainly serves alcohol.

HMRC, predictably argued that a bar is “somewhere where one can buy and drink alcoholic and other drinks, as well as food”, and that 92 met that definition.

The court agreed with HMRC that the bar was indeed a bar and did not grant permission to appeal.

So, now we know, a bar is a bar, not a café… or anything else really.

Technical

* Student unions often provide catering alongside universities. Since March 2002, HMRC has operated a published concession extending the exemption granted to supplies of catering made by universities to student unions.

VAT – Fuel and power guidance updated

By Marcus Ward 11 February 2025

HMRC has updated its notice Updated its Notice 701/19: Fuel and power.

The Notice explains how suppliers and users should treat supplies of fuel and power for VAT purposes and it sets out how to treat a number of other supplies connected with fuel and power.

The update provides more detail of supplies for domestic use.

Supplies of fuel and power for domestic use are eligible for the reduced rate of 5%.

The provider must be certain that the supply is to a dwelling or certain types of residential accommodation. Examples of allowed residential accommodation are:

armed forces residential accommodation
caravans
children’s homes
homes providing care for the elderly or disabled, people with a past or present dependence on alcohol or drugs or people with a past or present mental disorder
houseboats
houses, flats or other dwellings
hospices
institutions that are the sole or main residence of at least 90% of their residents
monasteries, nunneries and similar religious communities
school and university residential accommodation for students or pupils
self catering holiday accommodation

The following buildings are not considered residential accommodation for the purposes of fuel and power:

hospitals
prisons or similar establishments
hotels, inns or similar establishments

Updated VAT Notice 701/30: Education and vocational training

By Marcus Ward 3 February 2025

This notice covers how VAT applies to; education, research, vocational training, examination services and goods and services connected with these activities.

More information on exempt education here.

Since 1 January 2025, all education services and vocational training provided by private schools in the UK for a charge have been subject to VAT at the standard rate of 20%. This also applies to boarding services provided by private schools. The Notice been updated to include these changes.

A VAT Did you know?

By Marcus Ward 29 January 2025

Children’s clothing is zero rated. But where a child has one foot larger than the other, the pair of shoes can be zero-rated if the smaller shoe qualifies as a child’s size (boys 6 1/2 and girls; generally, size 3).