Tag Archives: partial-exemption

VAT: Revoke an option to tax after 20 years have passed – update

By   6 November 2023
0

HMRC’s Form VAT1614J has been updated. This form is used to revoke an option to tax (OTT) land or buildings for VAT purposes after 20 years have passed. There is a new address to which the form and supporting documents are sent:

BT VAT

HM Revenue and Customs

BX9 1WR

Scanned copies of the form can be emailed to: optiontotaxnationalunit@hmrc.gov.uk

 

Background: Revoking an option where more than 20 years have elapsed since it first had effect.

A business may revoke an OTT without prior permission from HMRC where more than 20 years have elapsed since the option first had effect. This is done by submitting the Form VAT1614J.

When the OTT first has effect: An OTT first had effect on the day it was exercised, or any later day that was specified when opting to tax.

Who can revoke: The relevant guidance VAT Notice 742A – which has the force of law here states that the ‘Taxpayer’ can revoke the OTT. The taxpayer is defined as the person who exercised the option to tax or is treated as making that option by virtue of a real estate election.

When the revocation will take effect: The revocation will take effect from the day that the taxpayer specifies when HMRC is notified, but this cannot be any earlier than the day on which the taxpayer notifies HMRC.

Outcomes of revoking an Option To Tax

  • any income (rent or sale) relating to the property becomes exempt
  • any input tax relating to the property is not recoverable (subject to the de minimis rules)
  • if no other taxable supplies are made a business must deregister

Revocation of option: The VAT Act 1994, Schedule 10, 25(1)(a).

VAT reliefs for charities – A brief guide

By   24 October 2023
0
Charities and Not For Profit (NFP) entities – A list of VAT reliefs in one place

Unfortunately, there is no “general” rule that charities are relieved of the burden of VAT.

In fact, charities have to contend with VAT in much the same way as any business. However, because of the nature of a charity’s activities, VAT is not usually neutral and often becomes an additional cost. VAT for charities often creates complex and time consuming technical issues which a “normal” business does not have to consider.

There are only a relatively limited number of zero rated reliefs specifically for charities and not for profit bodies, so it is important that these are taken advantage of. These are broadly:

  • advertising services* received by charities
  • purchase of qualifying goods for medical research, treatment or diagnosis
  • new buildings constructed for residential or non-business charitable activities
  • self-contained annexes constructed for non-business charitable activities
  • building work to provide disabled access in certain circumstances
  • building work to provide washrooms and lavatories for disabled persons
  • supplies of certain equipment designed to provide relief for disabled or chronically sick persons

* HMRC have set out its views on digital/online advertising in Revenue and Customs Brief 13 (2020): VAT charity digital advertising relief. 

There are also special exemptions applicable to supplies made by charities:

  • income from fundraising events
  • admissions to certain cultural events and premises
  • relief from “Options to Tax” on the lease and acquisition of buildings put to non-business use
  • membership subscriptions to certain public interest bodies and philanthropic associations
  • sports facilities provided by non-profit making bodies

Although treating certain income as exempt from VAT may seem attractive to a charity, it nearly always creates an additional cost as a result of the amount of input tax which may be claimed being restricted. Partial exemption is a complex area of the tax, as are calculations on business/non-business activities which fundamentally affect a charity’s VAT position.

The reduced VAT rate (5%) is also available for charities in certain circumstances:

  • gas and electricity in premises used for residential or non-business use by a charity
  • renovation work on dwellings that have been unoccupied for over two years
  • conversion work on dwellings to create new dwellings or change the number of dwellings in a building
  • installation of mobility aids for persons aged over 60

Additionally, there are certain Extra Statutory Concessions (*ESCs) which benefit charities. These zero rate supplies made to charities, these are:

  • certain printed stationery used for appeals
  • collection boxes and receptacles
  • lapel stickers and similar tokens, eg; remembrance day poppies

* ESCs are formal, published concessions but have no legal force.

We strongly advise that any charity seeks assistance on dealing with VAT to ensure that no more tax than necessary is paid and that penalties are avoided. Charities have an important role in the world, and it is unfair that VAT should represent such a burden and cost to them.

VAT: Partial exemption – updated HMRC guidance

By   17 October 2023
0

HMRC has published updated partial exemption guidance in Manual PE21500.

The main changes are in respect of updated case law, including the Royal Opera House Court of Appeal case dealing with the attribution of input tax.

In that case the CoA considered: the test of direct and immediate link, economic necessity, business/non-business, and chains of transactions.

VAT: Updated guidance for medical professionals

By   2 October 2023
0

HMRC has updated VAT Notice 701/57 – Health professionals and pharmaceutical products.

The changes, in summary, are:

Para 2.1 – Pharmacy technicians (only in England, Scotland and Wales) has been added to the meaning of a health professional list.

Para 2.5 – Services directly supervised by a pharmacist has been removed: Services that are not exempt from VAT.

Para 4.7 has been updated to make it clear when forensic physicians services are exempt healthcare.

Para 5.2 – Services supervised by pharmacists are now included when referring to a health professional: Exemption of care services performed by a person not enrolled on a statutory medical register.

The exemptions covered in the health and welfare area are complex and even slight differences in circumstances can change the VAT liability of a supply. Additionally, there are further exemptions for charities and NFP bodies and the age-old issue of business/non-business.

We advise that specialist advice is sought when considering the VAT position of supplies in this area.

A VAT Did you know?

By   20 September 2023
0

Dance classes in some EU countries are subject to different VAT rates depending on whether the dance style is considered artistic or entertainment. In the UK, belly dancing and ceroc lessons are standard rated, but ballet is exempt.

VAT: HMRC partial exemption guidance updated

By   18 September 2023
0

VAT Notice 706 has been updated on he option to send an email to get an approval for a partial exemption special method has been removed from sections 6.2, Appendix 2 and how to apply.

Para 6.2 – “Get approval for a special method

You cannot change your method without our prior approval. You must continue to use your current method, whether that is the standard method or a special method, until we approve or direct the use of another method or direct termination of its use.

You can get approval for a special method by using the online service.

If you are unable to use the online service, contact VAT Written Enquiries team by post.

You must explain clearly how your proposed method will work, you should see Appendix 2 in this guide.

When you propose a special method you must include a declaration that the method is fair from its effective date of application, and for the foreseeable future so that from its effective date a fair amount of input tax is recovered”.

 

Examples of special methods (PESM) are:

  • sectors and sub-sectors
  • multi pot
  • time spent
  • headcount
  • values
  • number of transactions
  • floor space
  • cost accounting system
  • pro-rata
  • combinations of the above methods

Partial Exemption guidance here

VAT: Electronic Invoicing (eInvoicing)

By   21 August 2023
0

The rules for sending, receiving and storing VAT invoices in an electronic format.

What is an eInvoicing?

eInvoicing is the transmission and storage of invoices in an electronic format without duplicate paper documents. The format may be a structured format such as XML or an unstructured format such as PDF.

The benefits of eInvoicing

eInvoicing offers significant advantages over paper invoices. The electronic transmission of documents in a secure environment usually provides for:

  • structured data for auditing
  • improved traceability of orders
  • decreased reliance on paper reducing storage and handling costs
  • rapid access and retrieval
  • improved cash flow
  • security and easier dispute handling

Currently, a business does not have to use eInvoicing, but if it does, in conjunction with paper invoices, (a so-called dual system) it can only do this for a short period, ie; if eInvoicing is being trialled.

It is not necessary to inform HMRC that a business is using eInvoicing.

Requirements

eInvoices must contain the same information as paper invoices.

A business may eInvoice where the “authenticity of the origin”, “integrity of invoice data”, and “legibility” can be ensured, and the customer agrees to receive eInvoices

  • authenticity of the origin means the assurance of the identity of the supplier or issuer of the invoice
  • integrity of content means that the invoice content has not been altered
  • legibility of an invoice means that the invoice can be easily read

A business is free to select a method of ensuring the above requirements. Examples of ensuring authenticity and integrity include:

Formats

HMRC accepts a variety of eInvoice message formats, including:

  • traditional EDI standards such as UN/EDIFACT, EANCOM and ODETTE
  • XML-based standards
  • comma-delimited ASCII, PDF

The eInvoices must be transmitted in a secure environment, using industry-accepted authenticity and security technologies, including, but not limited to: http-s, SSL, S-MIME and FTP.

Internal controls required

A business will need to demonstrate that it has control over:

  • completeness and accuracy of the invoice data
  • timeliness of processing
  • prevention, or detection of, the possible corruption of data during transmission
  • prevention of duplication of processing (by the person who receives the invoice)
  • prevention of the automatic processing, by the person who receives the invoice, of certain types of invoice on which VAT may not be recoverable – for example, margin scheme invoices
  • a recovery plan in case of a system failure or loss of data
  • an audit trail between eInvoicing systems and the internal application systems which are used to process the eInvoices

Storage

The same rules apply to storage of eInvoices as to paper invoices. A business must normally keep copies of all invoices for six years.

HMRC Access

HMRC may request access to:

  • the operations of any computer systems which produce or receive VAT invoices, and to the data stored on them
  • supporting documentation including; file structures, audit trail, controls, safe keeping, and information about how the accounting system is organised
  • information about the system’s interrogation facilities

HMRC must be able to take copies of information from the system.

If a business cannot meet the conditions for transmission and storage of eInvoicing, it will have to issue paper invoices.

Overages – what are they and what is the VAT treatment?

By   4 August 2023
0

Land and property transactions are often complex and high value for VAT purposes. One area which we have been increasingly involved with is overages.

What is an overage?

An overage is an agreement whereby a purchaser of land agrees to pay the vendor an additional sum of money, in addition to the purchase price, following the occurrence of a future specified event that enhances the value of the land. This entitles the seller to a proportion of the enhanced value following the initial sale. Overages may also be called clawbacks, or uplifts.

Overages are popular with landowners who sell with the benefit of development potential and with buyers who may be able to purchase land at an initial low price with a condition that further payment will be made contingent on land increasing in value in the future – this may be as a result, of, say, obtaining Planning Permission.

VAT Treatment

This is not free from doubt. HMRC’s current view is that the VAT treatment of the overage follows the VAT treatment of the initial supply. This means that it is deemed to be additional consideration for the original supply, so if the land was subject to an Option To Tax (OTT) when originally disposed of  the overage payment would be subject to VAT at 20%. Conversely, if the land was sold on an exempt basis, the overage is similarly VAT free and it is important to recognise this and not to charge VAT unnecessarily which would create difficulties for the buyer (because it would not be a VAT-able supply, HMRC would disallow a claim for input tax).

It is crucial to identify this VAT outcome, especially as there could be a long period between the original sale and the overage and there may be a succession of overage payments. Comprehensive records should be made and retained on the VAT status of land sold.

Uncertainty

Uncertainty arises because HMRC have changed its view on overages. The original interpretation was that there were two separate supplies, each with distinct VAT treatments. As there was no link to the original supply, the overage was mandatorily standard rated, even if the initial supply was exempt.

Additionally, take the position where the original sale was standard rated due to an OTT on the land, and the buyer subsequently built and sold new dwellings (which effectively disapplies the OTT via para 3, Notice 742A) it could be argued that the overage should be exempt as it is linked to the sale of the new houses.

We understand that HMRC’s analysis is that VAT treatment of overages is determined at the time of the original supply such that it cannot be affected by subsequent events.

In our view, the “new” HMRC view may be open to challenge – We await updated published guidance on this.

VAT refunds guidance

By   13 June 2023
0

VAT Claims

HMRC has completely rewritten its manual VRM7000 on VAT repayments and set-off.

When a business makes a claim for VAT (for whatever reason) HMRC have the power to set-off a payment against other amounts due.

HMRC also has a discretion to take account of any taxpayer liabilities in other regimes HMRC administers such as corporation tax or excise duty.

In summary, the new guidance covers:

  • Inherent set-off via The VAT General Regulations 1995, Section 80(2A) and Regulation 29. This is where, say, a supply was incorrectly treated as standard rated when it was exempt. It would not be possible to claim the overcharged output tax (subject to unjust enrichment) without recognising the potential overclaim of input tax as a result of partial exemption.
  • Set-off under The VAT Gen Regs 1995, Section 81(3) HMRC. This covers HMRC liability to only pay a claim after setting off any VAT, penalties, interest or surcharge owed to it. Section 81(3) is mandatory and applies to the current liabilities of a taxpayer, regardless of the period incurred.
  • Set-off under section 81(3A). This is a special provision which requires HMRC to set any liabilities that would otherwise be out-of-time to assess, against any amounts for which HMRC is liable under a claim. It does this by disregarding the assessment time limit, to undo all the consequences of a mistake.
  • VAT group set-offs. When a company leaves a VAT group, it is still jointly and severally liable under section 43(1) VAT Act 1994 for any outstanding debts of the group incurred while the company was a member. Any VAT claim by the ex-member will be subject to set-off against these group debts.
  • Set-offs against other taxes and duties. HMRC has the discretion under Section 130 of the Finance Act 2008 to set-off debts due from any other tax regimes HMRC is responsible for. This is subject to the insolvency rules in section 131 Finance Act 2008. A taxpayer should always check that no further liabilities have arisen since the claim was made.
  • Transfers of rights to claim to another person (Section 133 of the Finance Act 2008) – A claim will be subject to set-off of any outstanding liabilities to HMRC from both transferor and transferee. NB: HMRC policy is to make reasonable efforts to recover outstanding debts from the original creditor before applying set-off to the current creditors claim.

VAT: Charity exemption for show admittance – The Yorkshire Agricultural Society case

By   9 May 2023
0

Latest from the courts

In the Yorkshire Agricultural Society First Tier Tribunal (FTT) case the issue was whether payments for entry into the annual The Great Yorkshire Show qualified as exempt via The VAT Act 1994, Schedule 9, Group 12, item 1 –

“The supply of goods and services by a charity in connection with an event—

      1. that is organised for charitable purposes by a charity or jointly by more than one charity,
      2. whose primary purpose is the raising of money, and
      3. that is promoted as being primarily for the raising of money.”

HMRC raised an assessment on the grounds that the supply of admittance fell outwith the exemption so it was standard rated. It appears that this view was formed solely on the basis that the events were not advertised as fundraisers.

The exemption covers events whose primary purpose is the raising of money and which are promoted primarily for that purpose. HMRC contended that the events were not advertised as fundraisers and therefore the exemption did not apply. Not surprisingly, the appellant contended that all of the tests at Group 12 were fully met.

The FTT found difficulty in understanding HMRC’s argument. It was apparent from the relevant: tickets, posters and souvenir programmes all featured the words “The Great Yorkshire Show raises funds for the Yorkshire Agricultural Society to help support farming and the countryside”.

Decision

The FTT spent little time finding for the taxpayer and allowing the appeal. The assessment was withdrawn. There was a separate issue of the assessment being out of time, which was academic given the initial decision. However, The Tribunal was critical of HMRC’s approach to the time limit test (details in the linked decision). HMRC’s argument was that apparently, the taxpayer had brought the assessment on itself by not providing the information which HMRC wanted. The Judge commented: “That is not the same as HMRC being in possession of information which justified it in issuing the Assessment. It is an inversion of the statutory test”.

HMRC’s performance (or lack of it)

Apart from the clear outcome of this case, it also demonstrated how HMRC can get it so wrong. The FTT stated that it was striking that there was very little by way of substantive challenge by HMRC to the appellant’s evidence, nor any detailed exploration of it in cross-examination. The FTT, which is a fact-finding jurisdiction, asked a series of its own questions to establish some facts about the Society’s activities and the Show in better detail. No-one from HMRC filed a witness statement or gave evidence, even though HMRC, in its application to amend its Statement of Case, had said that the decision-maker would be giving evidence. The decision-maker did not give evidence. HMRC were wrong on the assessment and the time limit statutory test and did not cover itself in glory at the hearing.

Commentary

More evidence that if any business receives an assessment, it is always a good idea to get it reviewed. Time and time again we see HMRC make basic errors and misunderstand the VAT position. We have an excellent record on challenging HMRC decisions. Charities have a hard time of it with VAT, and while it is accurate to say that some of the legislation and interpretation is often complex for NFPs, HMRC do not help by taking such ridiculous cases.