In the current climate many businesses are struggling to make payments to HMRC. This clearly can have serious consequences and reduced income due to the Covid 19 coronavirus adds more problems.

This article looks at how to manage a VAT debt position; what can be done, and what not to do.

The first, and most important point to make is; do not ignore a tax debt. It will not go away and, in VAT there is, in most cases a four-year limit for assessing tax, but once assessed or declared, there is no time bar for collecting the debt.

HMRC look for a taxpayer to be taking steps to make a payment, or for a disclosure of the reason funds are unavailable. If HMRC’s Debt Management & Banking team have no idea of the cause of non-payment they will assume that the matter is being ignored and the full force of their powers are likely to be invoked. For background on HMRC’s VAT recovery procedures and powers see here. It is no surprise to learn that the extent of their powers is sweeping and formidable.

Is the VAT debt correct?

The first step is to establish whether a VAT debt is accurate. If it is a result of a normal return, then ensure the declaration is correct. If it is the result of an assessment by HMRC, always challenge it. In the majority of cases, we can assist with getting an assessment reduced or removed completely. A debt may be made up of a combination of; actual VAT, surcharges, penalties and interest

Time To Pay (TTP)

Such an arrangement with HMRC enables a debt to be spread over a period of time. This is usually, but not always, the most beneficial course of action. The process is that the taxpayer submits a proposal for settling the debt over a set period (a “best offer”) in instalments. HMRC may accept the offer, refuse it outright or make a “counter-offer”.

Matters to consider when submitting a VAT TTP proposal:

• The shorter the payment period proposed the more likely HMRC is to accept
• The sooner a TTP proposal is made the better
• HMRC is unlikely to agree a TTP longer than 12 months and most are for a significant shorter period
• An offer of an up-front payment also increases the chance of agreement
• An agreed TTP avoids penalties for late payment (as long as it is adhered to, otherwise penalties will apply)
• If payments are missed HMRC will withdraw from the TTP and the entire debt (plus penalties and interest) will become due immediately
• A TTP will avoid HMRC using its debt collection powers
• HMRC is likely to request sight of; cash flow forecasts, management accounts and company cash reserve details to evidence a ‘best offer”
• Also, information on; management of costs, potential sale of assets, availability of loans, other debts, ability to pay future VAT liabilities may be requested
• A business with a history of previous TTPs is less likely to be able to agree a new one
• If a formal TTP cannot be agreed, it is still beneficial for a business to make payments as and when they can be afforded. This keeps HMRC onside and may make discussions about future payment more fruitful

What HMRC expect

HMRC look for various ways a business can raise funds to pay a VAT debt, these include:

• Sale of assets
• Anticipated income, eg; large customer payment, contract or other demonstrable future income
• Bank or similar loans (including family members)
• Charge on home
• Alternative fundraising methods

The Debt Management & Banking staff have experience and knowledge of these methods and also use credit agencies.  

Summary

It is always important to talk to HMRC. An ongoing dialogue can improve the debt situation and avoid HMRC taking unilateral action – which is nearly always detrimental to a business. Check that the debt is correct. Consider a TTP arrangement or alternative ways to raise funds. Talk to your advisers.

A debt is often the result of an assessment and penalties. A look at penalties (and how to avoid them) here and an article on how to survive HMRC’s enforcement powers here.