The changes will come into effect on:
The press release is available here.
VAT penalties for late submissions
HMRC has updated its Internal Guidance VGROUPS01530 on penalties for late submissions,
Penalties for late submissions are calculated on the basis of points.
For VAT groups the representative member has a single liability for these points covering the whole group. If the representative member changes, the existing liability is transferred to the new representative member. A new member joining the group will not affect the points total of the group, even if the member joining had points before. If a business leaves the group and registers for VAT separately they will start with zero points, even if the group that they left had a penalty point balance.
For divisions, each one is liable for its own separate points and penalties. Each division will have its own maximum points total.
HMRC has introduced new penalty and interest rules for late returns and payments from 1 January 2023. Details here.
On 4 January 2023 HMRC published guidance on how to remove these points to avoid a penalty. This is particularly important if a business has reached the penalty point threshold.
The penalty thresholds are:
If a business is at the limit and has the maximum points allowed for its accounting periods, it can remove them by meeting two conditions which are:
The guidance sets out how these tests are calculated and applied.
I have looked at the Default Surcharge regime in detail here but as statistics show more business to be in default (which is probably accurately attributable, inter alia, to the pandemic) I consider how a penalty may be mitigated, by the provision of a “Reasonable Excuse”. HMRC has updated its internal guidance on Reasonable Excuse this month.
Specifically: HMRC state that “…where a person has not been able to meet an obligation on time due to the impact of COVID-19, HMRC will usually accept that they will have a reasonable excuse.”
What is a Default Surcharge?
The Default Surcharge is a civil penalty issued by HMRC to encourage businesses to submit their VAT returns and pay the tax due on time.
A default occurs if HMRC has not received your return and all the VAT due by the due date. The relevant date is the date that cleared funds reach HMRC’s bank account. If the due date is not a working day, payment must be received on the last preceding working day.
More on late returns here and on late payments here.
New rules forthcoming
It is noted that there is a new regime for penalties, details here although these changes have been delayed until 1 January 2023
Reasonable Excuse
If a business has a reasonable excuse for failing to pay on time, and it remedies this failure without unreasonable delay after the excuse ends, it will not be liable to a surcharge. The onus is on a business to satisfy HMRC that it has a Reasonable Excuse.
Definition
There’s no statutory definition of Reasonable Excuse and it will depend on the particular circumstances of a case. A Reasonable Excuse is something that prevented the business meeting a tax obligation on time which it took reasonable care to meet. There is a great deal of case law on this particular issue. Please contact us should there be doubt about a Reasonable Excuse.
What may count as a Reasonable Excuse?
HMRC give the following examples:
This list is not exhaustive.
What is NOT a reasonable excuse
Statute identifies two specific situations that are not a reasonable excuse:
There can be exceptions to these two exclusions. For example, an insufficiency of funds may be a reasonable excuse where the insufficiency is a result of events outside the person’s control.
HMRC also states that these situations would not normally be accepted, on their own, as a reasonable excuse:
Facts
HMRC will establish what facts the business believes gave rise to a Reasonable Excuse. The facts may include:
Case Law
Although not a VAT issue, in the Upper Tribunal (UT) case of Christine Perrin [2018] UKUT 156 [TC], the judge provided guidance on how the Tribunal should approach a Reasonable Excuse defence. There are four steps:
Appeal
If HMRC refuse to accept an advance of a Reasonable Excuse and the Default Surcharge is maintained, there are two potential remedies:
If a business disagrees with a decision that it is liable to a surcharge or how the amount of surcharge has been calculated, it is possible to:
If you ask for a review of a case, a business will be required to write to HMRC within 30 days of the date the Surcharge Liability Notice Extension (SLNE) was sent. The letter should give the reasons why a business disagrees with the decision.
We are able to assist with all disputes with HMRC and have an enviable record of succeeding in having Default Surcharges removed.
The current late payment and repayment interest rates applied to the main taxes and duties that HMRC currently charges and pays interest on are:
Interest rates for all other taxes here.
Details of default surcharge here.
What is the Default Surcharge?
Default Surcharge is a civil penalty to “encourage” businesses to submit their VAT returns and pay the tax due on time the charge is introduced via VATA 1994 s 59(A).
When will a Default Surcharge be issued?
A business is in default if it sends in its VAT return and or the VAT due late. No surcharge is issued the first time a business is late but a warning – a Surcharge Liability Notice (SLN) is issued. Subsequent defaults within the following twelve months – the “surcharge period” may result in a surcharge assessment. Each time that a default occurs the surcharge period will be extended. There is no liability to a surcharge if a nil or repayment return is submitted late, or the VAT due is paid on time but the return is submitted late (although a default is still recorded).
How much is the surcharge?
The surcharge is calculated as a percentage of the VAT that is unpaid at the due date. If no return is submitted the amount of VAT due will be assessed and the surcharge based on that amount. The rates are:
A surcharge assessment is not issued at the 2% and 5% rates if it is calculated at less than £200 but a default is still recorded and the surcharge period extended. At the 10% and 15% the surcharge will be the greater of the calculated amount or £30.
Specific issues
The default surcharge can be particularly swingeing for a fast-growing company. Let’s say that a small company grows quickly. In the early days the administration was rather haphazard, as is often the case, and a number of returns and payments were submitted late. Fast forward and the turnover, and the VAT payable, has grown significantly. Being late at this time means that the amount of default surcharge is considerably higher than when the original default which created the surcharge took place. This leads us onto whether the surcharge is proportionate.
A business with cashflow difficulties may well ask whether it should be penalised by HMRC for having those difficulties; which of course will add to the problem.
Proportionality
The existing, long-standing default surcharge regime has always had issues with the principle of proportionality. The regime has regularly been challenged in the Courts.
Is it proportionate that a same penalty is applied for a payment which is one day late and one which is one year late? This is a matter which has concerned both HMRC and the Courts for a number of years.
In the Upper Tribunal case of Total Technology (Engineering) Ltd the Judge concluded that it was possible for an individual surcharge to be disproportionate, but that the system as a whole was not fundamentally flawed. It is also worth noting that in In Equoland judgment the judge stated that a penalty which is automatic and does not take into account the circumstances is at the least tending towards being disproportionate.
Disagreement over a surcharge
If you disagree with a decision that you are liable to surcharge or how the amount of surcharge has been calculated, it is possible to:
If you ask for a review of a case, a business will be required to write to HMRC within 30 days of the date the Surcharge Liability Notice Extension was sent. The letter should give the reasons why you disagree with the decision.
Defence against a surcharge
In order to have a surcharge withdrawn (it cannot be reduced, as it is one of the few penalties that cannot be mitigated in any circumstances) it is necessary to demonstrate that a business had a reasonable excuse for the default. This is a subject of an article on its own. Certain factors, like relaying on a third party are not accepted as a reasonable excuse. HMRC state that a business will not be in default if they, or the independent tribunal, agree that there is a reasonable excuse for failing to submit a VAT Return and/or payment on time.
There is no legal definition of reasonable excuse but HMRC will look closely at the circumstances that led to the default.
If the circumstance that led to the default were unforeseen and inescapable and a business is able to show that its conduct was that of a conscientious person who accepted the need to comply with VAT requirements, then it may amount to a reasonable excuse.
What sort of circumstances might count as reasonable excuse?
HMRC provide guidelines on circumstances where there might be a reasonable excuse for failing to submit a VAT Return and/or payment on time. These include:
Ongoing issues
HMRC is considering whether and how it should differentiate between those who deliberately and persistently fail to meet administrative deadlines or to pay what they should on time, and those who make occasional and genuine errors for which other responses might be more appropriate. This has been a lengthy process to date.
A previous HMRC document highlighted two issues with the current VAT default surcharge regime.
It is possible that in the future we may hear proposals for the system being amended. if this is the case, I think we can anticipate the introduction of mitigation and suspension.