The latest figures from the Ministry of Justice show that for fraud offences including; VAT, Excise Duty, and Custom Duty the average length of custodial sentences has increased by around 25%. The average sentence is now four years one month, up from three years three months as the government clamps down on tax evasion.
Why longer in jail?
It is thought that the reasons for this are that:
- HMRC is demanding longer sentences
- HMRC is pursuing an increasing number of suspected fraudsters
- HMRC is devoting more resources to carrying out investigations
- CPS has been pushing for tax frauds to be considered as a more serious offence (which, obviously, carry longer sentences).
Criminal prosecution has also increased enormously as a result of the Revenue and Customs Prosecutions Office being incorporated with the CPS. HMRC is no longer just interested in getting the VAT, it wants prosecutions, the convictions….and the tax. A person criminally prosecuted for evasion does not escape paying the tax and they will be chased for it. A fraudster may be prosecuted under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 and the Money Laundering Act 2007.
More resources
The news comes as companies including Amazon and eBay have agreed to give their data to HMRC in an effort to crack down on VAT evasion by overseas retailers. The deal will mean the companies will provide merchant’s data to tax officials so that fraudulent trends can be spotted.
HMRC have also been using increasingly technical procedures on data which was previously unavailable to them – details here
Naming and shaming
In addition, HMRC also publish details of people who deliberately “get their tax affairs wrong”. The current list is here
What is evasion, and what is the difference between that and avoidance?
I am often asked about the distinction between avoidance and evasion. Broadly, the difference between avoidance and evasion is legality. Tax avoidance is legally exploiting the tax system to reduce current or future tax liabilities by means not intended by Parliament. It often involves artificial transactions that are contrived to produce a tax advantage. Tax avoidance is not the same as tax planning or mitigation.
Tax evasion is to escape paying taxes illegally. This is usually when a person misrepresents or conceals the true state of their affairs to tax authorities, for example dishonest tax reporting.
Technical
The relevant legislation covering the offences of fraudulent evasion of VAT is under section 72(1) of the Value Added Tax Act 1994, furnishing false information under section 72(3) and committing evasion over a period under section 72(8). Section 72(8)(b) sets out that the offence is subject to”…imprisonment for a term not exceeding seven years…”.
Summary
The message is clear; after being criticised by the Public Accounts Committee for not have a clear strategy for dealing with tax fraud and not pursuing criminal prosecution in enough cases HMRC has demonstrated that it is prepared to go after more businesses and individuals and put more resources into detecting and prosecuting fraudulent activities.
Sleep tight
We always recommend full disclosure to HMRC, it is preferable to sleep at night (rather than trying to sleep in a prison cell). Of course, the very best course of action is not to commit tax fraud…